Theatre of Blood stars Vincent Price as actor Edward Lionheart. His enemies: critics such as Peregrine Devlin, Meredith Merridew, Solomon Psaltery, Oliver Larding, Horace Sprout, and Hector Snipe.
You can tell a lot about a movie from its character names. There’s no more effective way to indicate the desired level of reality: are we diligently choosing common handles out of baby name books and historical registers, accounting for any exceptions as stage names or offshoots of unusual parents? Or are we channeling Dickens and Dahl, saddling everyone with names that truly embody them in sound and plain meaning?
It’s obvious to see what route Theatre of Blood goes down. The artificiality technically sacrifices a bit of realism, but you know what? This is a film about a hammy actor who survives his own suicide attempt to commit elaborate themed murders on the critics who failed to reward his season of Shakespearean posturing. No one here is going for realism. The names offer the same handcrafted pleasure as a painted backdrop, a puppet, and red corn syrup.
Theatre of Blood is technically classed as a horror comedy, but its truest genre is camp. Genre is partly a confession of priorities, and at any point, if this has to choose between the scariest choice, the funniest choice, or the campiest choice, it will choose the latter. Vincent Price, clearly having the time of his life here, wouldn’t have it any other way; by 1973, when this was released, he had spent decades bringing this kind of enlivening exaggeration to the screen. Here, the script is fully cooperating with him. Have all the costumes: chef, hair stylist, masseur, fencer. (The one failing here is that we do not get Price in drag, but to compensate, Lionheart’s loyal daughter, Edwina (Diana Rigg), spends a huge chunk of the film as a not-all-that-convincing drag king.) Have wigs and fake facial hair. Drown a man in a vat of wine and bake two poodles into a pie. Life is short, and camp refuses to care. It will go out defiantly partying and rigging hair dryers into electrical chairs.
It doesn’t matter that none of this is plausible and that the plot is mostly an excuse to propel us from one bizarre murder tableau to the next. In a way, the weird disconnects—would Lionheart really have continued to have a major career on the Shakespearean stage if every major critic routinely dismissed or slammed him? Weren’t they right to dismiss and slam him, since what we see of his acting is almost uniformly terrible?—make it better, because they prove the film has little interest in adopting a moral stance that could only interfere with its actual aesthetic purpose. This isn’t about convincing you the critics deserve it or don’t, it’s about “uh-oh, Titus Andronicus is next on the docket.”
When morality—the result of narrative, not style—does come into play, it does so, unsurprisingly, in the film’s two strongest instances of actual plotting, a neat bit of story construction that shows how fundamentally good writer Anthony Greville-Bell and director Douglas Hickox’s instincts really are.
Part of it is Peregrine Devlin (Ian Hendry), the head of the circle that unanimously denied Price the capstone of his career. He’s Lionheart’s ultimate antagonist, so he has to embody what Lionheart cannot—a sober, consistent perspective—but with Lionheart’s own passions and field of references. We hardly ever the other critics mention the theater, but Devlin truly cares about it. To an extent, he even cared about Lionheart as part of it: one of his early defining scenes is telling Edwina, with all apparent honesty, that he criticized her father partly because he felt Lionheart’s decision to stick only with Shakespeare shortchanged Lionheart’s own talent and development. He awarded another actor over Lionheart because he remains committed that the other actor is better and more promising. Of course Lionheart can’t let go of this more substantiated disapproval, so he tries repeatedly to bully Devlin over to his side, fencing him at the movie’s midpoint in a nonfatal duel and finally offering to spare him Gloucester’s fate in exchange for a private, “corrected” award show. Devlin can’t, because if he succumbs to save his own skin, he becomes—however understandable—faintly silly, ceding his ground. He can’t survive on Lionheart’s territory. All he can do is hold his own, even with red-hot daggers aimed at his eyes, and hope for the best.
If Lionheart thinks too much of his critics, however, what really gets him—and what is the cherry on top of the film’s surprisingly strong late-game plotting—is that he doesn’t think enough of his audience and co-stars. He kept on getting cast as a headliner even after all the pans, so the audience must have loved him, but he found no solace there; in reconstructing his life after his suicide attempt, he finds little solace in his ongoing audience, either. A crowd of smudge-faced unhoused characters save him from death and offer him their help, and Lionheart uses them relentlessly, condescending to them and enlisting them in his war against his critics. When they first deliver him from the river, saving him from drowning, he has his Tempest moment—for a split second, he’s Miranda discovering a brave new world—but it doesn’t take long for him to lose that sense of ingenue wonder and declare himself king of this refuge. He’ll be Prospero, and they’ll all be his Calibans. He uses them without mercy or regard, and Edwina, reflecting his wishes and enforcing them, calls him their “master” and punishes them when their attention wanders during his monologues. These people are part of his plan and part of his performance, but he has no regard for them, and in the end, he pays for it.
Maybe you can’t win an award if you have no one to thank.
Theatre of Blood is streaming on Tubi.
About the writer
Lauren James
Lauren James is a writer who wears many different hats (and pen names). She lives in Connecticut with her wife and two cats.
Lauren James’s ProfileTags for this article
More articles by Lauren James
Anthologized
Dan Duryea gets a shave and a second chance.
Anthologized
A little slice of American folklore that feels like it's been here all along.
Streaming Shuffle
You make your royal bed, and you lie in it.
Anthologized
Alone in vast space and timeless infinity: one man in a ghost town.
Department of
Conversation
What did we watch?
Justified, Season Four, Episode Eleven, “Decoy”
“God, I love the way you talk. You said forty words where four will do.”
I wish more pure entertainment was like this. Imagine if the MCU had this mixture of basic plotting and dedication to a cool veneer. There’s elements of Theme in this show, but it’s mainly cool flavour to the action. Raylan has a great moment where he undercuts Drew trying to get ahold of a gun on the basis of seeing out his last moments, pointing out that he’s fallen hard on the criminal side of the criminal/cop line, as well as Drew contemplating the nature of facing one’s death mere minutes away. One way people are drawn to Christianity in particular is that it justifies the suffering you’re going through now.
Biggest Laugh: “You sure about this?” / “Oh, no, I’m having a full-on PTSD moment.” / “You get those a lot?” / “Only when I’m handling firearms in public.” Included despite Art actually being the comic foil here because it has Tim doing a very Art-like joke.
Biggest Non-Art Laugh: Colt pointing out that Tim’s fictional character has the same name as the character from Forrest Gump (“Shit, you’re right, I’m gonna change that.”).
Top Ownage: Gotta give it to Bob vs Yolo. This is that ordinary heroism you only ever see every once in a while.
Surely one of my favorite TV episodes of all time. As a former Kentuckian, btw, I will vouch for Art’s point that to an extent, a bizarre number of deserted cars is just typical (“That’s Kentucky“). Bob vs. Yolo and this glorious Tim vs. Colt exchange in one episode? This is about as cool as anything can possibly get.
I love the point you get where you realise Tim isn’t actually making it up about writing that book.
Can you also vouch for Art’s bafflement that nobody smokes?
Oh yeah. I always knew people there who smoked! Back in Indiana, too: my first kiss was with someone who had developed the habit years ahead of being able to buy cigarettes legally.
The crooks being genuinely impressed/shocked that Bob killed Yolo is great, another Leonardian moment of people being people even in extreme situations.
Inside No. 9, “Thinking Out Loud”
The first episode I would not cheerfully rewatch? This starts off strong, with a lot of disparate characters–the most affecting is Shearsmith’s, who has terminal cancer and knows he won’t live to see his baby daughter born; this could be treacly but instead feels real and rueful–unified by the theme of all talking to a camera in some capacity (video dating, therapy, vlogging, prison interview with a serial killer, etc.). For a while, it feels like it might be setting up a technical cheat that I was willing to give it (revealing, This Is Us-style, that the characters were all more spaced out in time than it appeared, and we were spanning generations), but instead it went with “they’re all fragments of one split personality,” my second least favorite standard twist in existence.
I’m not even opposed on the grounds that it’s a really inaccurate portrayal of DID–I mean, it is, and I fully get why people with that condition are extra-aggravated that this is a standard genre move, but I like ridiculous amnesia storylines, so I don’t have a leg to stand on there; I’m opposed on the grounds that at this point it’s trite and annoying, and it kneecaps the human drama I’ve been invested in and replaces it with nonsense. Good production design here, though, and an Exorcist III homage. And it’s nice to have a clear least favorite episode so far, when I’m spoiled for choice on what my favorite would be.
Rewatched “Once Removed” after this as a palate cleanser. Then:
Taskmaster, “9 x 7”
The British game shows I’ve seen have all been much more fun than American game shows, especially when they’re excuses to watch professionally funny people being very funny, and that continues here. (Yes, I picked this season because it has one of the Inside No. 9 guys on it; yes, I will also then be watching the other season that has the other one. I apologize for nothing. People are lucky to be liked by me.)
For the unfamiliar, which included me until last night, this is a hilarious comedy game show where Greg Davies and Alex Horne recruit people to perform absurd tasks that are scored in a sometimes technical, sometimes eccentric manner. This episode’s tasks included elaborate bowling, bringing in something very soft, making disgusting noises behind a curtain while actually doing something very nice, chasing Alex Horne around a garden to scan a QR code on his back, etc.: lots of daftness, lots of weird scenarios to produce comedy, and some straightforward physical challenges that are nonetheless very funny in execution. Highlights: Maisie accidentally finishing the QR code challenge in seconds, Reece’s Count Orlok impression (and his pissiness at Alex not getting it; I feel very seen), Reece and Sanjeev being hilariously bad with the QR code due to being less experienced with their phones, Sanjeev’s tire bowling, and “I just pretended to be attacked and then made a cocktail.”
I’ll probably take a leaf out of Tristan’s book and do future Taskmaster write-ups solely as a series of quotes.
Sanjeev’s presence here also led to me watching the most famous sketch from Goodness Gracious Me, “Going for an English,” which was very funny: my favorite bit is ordering 24 plates of chips for the table.
I’ve only actually seen one episode of Taskmaster, I’d probably fail a citizenship test.
My influence continues to spread.
The Practice, “The Verdict” – The Verdict is a very good courtroom drama with Paul Newman. “The Verdict” is a bog standard episode of a show suddenly out of steam at the end of its sixth season. A year after Bobby was tried and acquitted for the murder of someone stalking Lindsay in a case where he clearly had some culpability, he was acquitted. Now, Lindsay is treated for killing another stalker, and is clearly coming undone, and she’s found guilty. A wry commentary on how juries treat men and women differently? Or just pure overwrought David E. Kelley melodrama. But guess what, we aren’t done yet. Season seven and all its pains lurk.
MASH, “Bug-Out” – After a day of rumors, and with the Chinese army getting closer, the entire unit flees. Except for Hawkeye, Margaret, and Radar, who have to keep watch on a patient who can’t be moved for 24 hours. Let’s ignore the fact that real MASH units could and did move often (they took that M seriously) and with ease. And let’s ignore how quickly the whole thing is undone. This one is just a lot of fun when it’s not being serious. “Stand by for the blessing” is one of my all time favorite MASH moments. So begins the fifth season, which will be a year of big changes and classic moments.
The Pitt, S2E4 – Get that date, McKay! Maybe because it’s July 4th weekend (god what I’d give for a real heat wave here), there’s more dating stuff this season. Robby and Al-Hashimi naturally have chemistry, being attractive, experienced older people working side by side, even with some friction, though he’s possibly hooking up with an insurance lady at the hospital too. Mel’s bashful explanation to Santos of her own flirtation is hilarious (“I mean, he turned out to be a criminal, but…”) and you also have McKay’s flirty charmer of a patient. Other threads here are Ogilvie and Javadi each fucking up – the therapist’s reaction to the sedated patient is very funny and makes sense given that he’s in a wheelchair, and going up and down floors is a pain in the ass – and really the simple miracle of medicine. McKay’s patient is astonished at how much better he feels with a hand up the posterior and “Dr. J” cuts a lash, and boom, eye is restored. (Langdon is having too much fun with Dr. J’s social media following.)
The “Dr. J” reveal made me so happy. I was waiting for you to get to that part!
The Santos/Garcia hookup being confirmed via Whitaker and Garcia’s mutual snark about him accidentally using her toothbrush is another bit of implied romance this season, and that was the best way to tip the hat to it.
McKay’s hot patient doing his best to flirt with her from across the ER reveals true dedication. And he’s into art galleries! Good for you, McKay!
Indeed, it’s hilarious and Langdon’s enjoyment of it is a fun moment for him in the midst of humiliation.
He’s so hot, good for her!
Seinfeld, end of S6 – “The Face Painter” was pretty great, Patrick Warburton’s second appearance has rocketed him up in the charts of my favourite recurring guest stars (charts I hadn’t considered until now, so I guess he’s at the top). Kramer’s feud with a monkey also very funny, and George struggling to say “I love you”.
“The Understudy” felt a bit like it had been thrown together quickly because they realised they could get a big-name guest star, it felt a bit scrappy somehow. But Bette Midler is very funny, so I’m going to allow it. I had no previous knowledge of the J. Peterman Company but that joke became pretty funny very quickly anyway.
Hell yeah! Letterboxd says I’ve seen 47 Vincent Price movies and I’d rank this one top of the pile.
Not that Price ever really had a leash, but this still somehow feels like Price: Unleashed!
Alright, I’m gonna watch this maybe tonight. To Tubi! Or Shudder!
Obviously the correct streaming option here is Fawesome.
I saw this on TV in my early teens, and really loved it for it’s gross humor. I’ve got to revisit this soon, as I’d probably get more of the jokes.
I hope your teen self was appropriately delighted by Price pulling a long piece of dog hair out of a meat pie.