Close Search Close

 

  • Comics
  • Theatre
  • Site News

The Sounding Board

Dari Bay's Surprise Wish is a welcome surprise

A weekly column where New Music Tuesdays live on. Conversation is encouraged in the comments.

Surprise Wish

Every Tuesday, the Sounding Board is a space for a short-ish review of a recent-ish release and conversations about new-to-you music. We’ll get things started with a write-up about a newer, likely under-heard album, and invite you to share your music musings in the comments.

When I finished college, I had six figures of debt, an unhealthy relationship with alcohol and a physical binder full of student newspaper clips I was certain would secure my professional future.1

I’m reasonably sure nothing in those three-ringed confines was as accomplished as Surprise Wish, the second album Zachary James has made under the name Dari Bay.2

Surprise Wish, which came together as James wrapped up college,3 is an agreeable riff-centric slab of slacker rock dappled with flecks of Midwest emo. The emo bits come into focus when acoustic guitar or James’ upper register manage to take suction-cup steps atop thrumming electric guitar gloop that provides the LP’s foundation. These moments add extra tunefulness and a sincerity to an album that mostly works within a genre known for ironic detachment.

The slacker rock piece of the equation is self-evident. Sludgy riffs ebb and flow leisurely throughout, giving songs a steady but far-from-frantic drive. Record scratching charmingly, but perhaps regrettably, appears on multiple songs.4 Listeners can expect ample reason to bob their heads but zero occasions for headbanging across Surprise Wish’s nine songs. Even “The Joke,” which stands as a self-contained Maladroit amid the rest of the album’s Blue Album-plus-Benadryl intensity,5 doesn’t quite cross that threshold. It features fun moments of dive-bombing noise but also includes lyrics about being the last person at a party, feeling lost and lonely and, crucially, taking a big hit and getting too high.

While there isn’t drastic variance in tempo among songs, James does find ways to set tracks apart. “Chevy” includes muted twinkling in its opening moments that sounds like hearing “Love is Greed” by Passion Pit drifting through a vent.6 “How Can You Tell” has a distinctive low end thanks to a guest bassist.7 “We’re Going to Be OK” evokes optimism as James produces quivering high notes with his voice and guitar. “Finder,” which opens the album, starts soft before growing louder and layered. The end result sounds a bit muddled, but the attempt to establish a majestic tone to get the album in motion is appreciated. 

It’s also a handy analog to the album as a whole. Surprise Wish is a well-intentioned, reasonably well-executed album that is inoffensive even when it stumbles. It’s not an LP that anyone should reasonably expect to set the world on fire, but it’s a well-made throwback with several good songs and zero outright bad ones.

That praise is somewhat faint, but it’s sincerely meant to be praise. It also doesn’t diminish how impressive it is that Surprise Wish is essentially the work of a one-man band, self-produced and made up of songs that came together with a collegiate graduation still looming. It’s a backstory that suggests that, as solid as Dari Bay is now, James’ best music is probably ahead of him.

  1. And a degree, but rule of threes. ↩︎
  2. Released June 26, 2026, on Double Double Whammy, an indie label started by the guys from LVL Up. I remember liking LVL Up in the early ’10s, but my memories of their music are hazy at best and not just because there were a lot of pop-punk bands with a love for the caps lock key at that time. See the opening paragraph of this column. ↩︎
  3. Per Surprise Wish‘s Bandcamp page: “Surprise Wish came together slowly over time as James balanced multiple projects while finishing college…” ↩︎
  4. Slacker rock and hip-hop have long had a cozy relationship, so it’s a fun throwback move, but the scratching is deployed despite a lack of clear samples, musical stuttering, pitch change or any other indicator that something is being mixed. ↩︎
  5. Like Zachary James, Weezer maestro Rivers Cuomo has ties to New England. ↩︎
  6. My memories of Passion Pit’s early ’10s output are tack-sharp. ↩︎
  7. That guest is Owen James, Zachary’s brother. ↩︎