The Sounding Board
A weekly column where New Music Tuesdays live on. Conversation is encouraged in the comments.
Every Tuesday, the Sounding Board is a space for a short-ish review of an upcoming or recent-ish release and conversations about new-to-you music. We’ll get things started with a write-up about a newer, likely underheard album, and invite you to share your music musings in the comments.
Power Pop sickos, Frets by Letters of Acceptance is definitely for you.
The melodic, melancholic album also offers plenty for people who can’t tell the Go-Betweens from the dB’s.1 However, the Kentucky four-piece band’s latest is ideal for any achy former children who still sing for Alex Chilton when his ghost comes round. It is a light, bright, tight and ultra-catchy collection of mid-tempo rockers forged in grief.2
“The period preceding this record contained a lot of loss for every member of the band,” John Norris, one of the band’s two founding singer-guitarists, recently told Remember the Lightning. “To keep it simple, there was a time when it seemed like we were seeing each other at wakes more than at band practice.”
That’s readily apparent on the album.
Loss, guilt and other dark emotions are foundational to the cleverly titled Frets. Equally important is warm, pleasantly layered guitar pop. The LP’s pleasant, harmonic sound can somewhat obscure its anguished sentiments, but they’re never fully hidden. Lyrics sit like a dark sheen atop the music’s placid surface and address hardship directly. Thanatological turns of phrase, fatalistic thoughts and drab imagery are nearly omnipresent on Frets, and even unattentive listeners are likely to pick up on the thematic gloom.
Lead single “In Sunken Style” opens with the lines “She’s a conveyor on the layer where the dead ones lie/ She sells their secrets, sorts their trinkets into numbered file.” “Penny in the Lake” closes with the heartbreaking survivor’s sentiment “I know the world won’t end with you/ But it’s a start/ Wherever you are/ I have to stay/ Here at least one more day.” “Don’t Forget to Be Happy” preaches the importance of optimism, but uses rabid faces, bleeding capillaries, and an afterlife deferred to make its point.
It’s real poetic sadsack stuff that at points borders on Dark Romanticism, especially when delicate rock and long blue veins enter the picture. Album-closer, “Broken Guitars (and Fucked Up Feelings),” would have been an apt title track.
The grim feelings are kept from creating a harrowing quagmire because they’re given voice over 10 songs that make the Exploding Hearts sound like Slayer.
On Frets, Letters of Acceptance’s sound is almost always gentle, sunny and fueled by the interplay of the band’s two vocalist-guitarists, Norris and Clint Newman.3 Twelve-string jangle, smooth vocal harmonies, sensible guitar solos and the occasional incursion of Americana4 are the prevailing musical winds. That keeps the ship on course and moving at a good clip despite perpetually cloudy skies.
There is theoretical tension inherent to the oil-and-water nature of Frets’ lyrics and music, but it’s a far less jarring choice in practice than it is when it’s dissected and prodded in a review. The dark lyrics-meets-light music combination works well for Letters of Acceptance. It also sounds completely natural and earned.
That’s partly because Letters of Acceptance clearly take their craft seriously,5 have a decade and change of history and wrote what they know. It’s also because the tension is superficial. Joy, dread, hurt and hope are links in a chain that have a long history in song, including nearly all of the best power pop.
The genre has almost always used hyper-pleasant sounds to grapple with unpleasant feelings. Unrequited love, soul-deep sadness and internal tumult are at the heart of the genre’s canon. That applies to even the most playful stuff. Even “Surrender” by Cheap Trick blends cheeky rolling record misdirects with generational disconnect and the dawning of the surreal realization that parents are people with histories, too.6 The sticky melodies and slick harmonies make power pop compulsively listenable and provide a Trojan Horse for the genre’s terminally bummed-out core. In turn, the barely concealed hurt and despair grant power pop depth and provide greater significance to moments of joy or triumph.
Letters of Acceptance demonstrably understand how and why that sweet-and-sour approach works. That makes for a good listening experience for anyone, but September gurls and December boys are going to really get it good.
About the writer
Ben Hohenstatt
Ben Hohenstatt is an Alaska-based dog owner who moonlights as a music writer and photographer.
For more information, consult your local library or with parental permission visit his website.
Tags for this article
More articles by Ben Hohenstatt
The Sounding Board
A weekly column where New Music Tuesdays live on. Conversation is encouraged in the comments.
The Sounding Board
A weekly column where New Music Tuesdays live on. Conversation is encouraged in the comments.
The Sounding Board
A weekly column where New Music Tuesdays live on. Conversation is encouraged in the comments.
The Sounding Board
A weekly column where New Music Tuesdays live on. Conversation is encouraged in the comments.
The Sounding Board
A weekly column where New Music Tuesdays live on. Conversation is encouraged in the comments.
Department of
Conversation
What did we watch?
Superstore, Season Two, Episode Thirteen, “Ladies’ Lunch”
“Why are you waving the cash around?”
“Oh, I thought it would make you excited, like I was gonna give you the cash or something.”
“You know what? It’s probably drugs. You can tell by her teeth.”
“It is not drugs! It’s marriage counselling!”
“Oh!”
“How is that worse than drugs?!”
“A tiny spider once crawled into the entrance of my…. mmm…”
“We can gab and dish and talk about our periods! Your reds don’t usually start until the 24th, right?”
“I’m dating Jeff! She’s dating no one! That’s how the world works!”
“In your face, Brett!”
“Kidnapping is what you do to children. You’re an adult, I abducted you.”
Jonah and Garrett just playing is great. Reminds me of Troy and Abed.
“I’m gonna have to see some ID.”
“Are you kidding? Look at her face, she’s like two thousand.”
“We make love on silk sheets.”
That slow zoom during Sandra’s monologue is great.
Carol is a great character to throw in. Real great case of the face being the backstory. In general this show is great at casting regular-looking actors who look like people you’d see working in a place like that, and they have a lot of fun with their material.
“I know it’s weird but this food smells like bowling.”
“I’ve had the same haircut since I was in high school.”
“Okay, I wasn’t finished talking, but I guess this game has made monsters out of all of us.”
Sandra looking sad while everyone drunkenly sings “Don’t You Forget About Me” killed me, it was so fucking funny.
Drunk Dina stumbling around the store also killed me, because I do exactly the same thing to my food when drunk.
“I can’t follow you because you talk, so much…” Okay, laugh for laugh, this is the best episode.
Elementary, “The Further Adventures” – After a year in London, Sherlock and Joan are thriving as detectives, and have reunited with their former protege Kitty, but Joan is not really happy there (signified by her dyeing her hair blond, which really suits her). Their case today involves an acid attack on a News of the World model, and turns out not to be a mugging or a hate crime. (I had no idea how common acid attacks have been in London.) Meanwhile in NYC, Gregson is bitter over how things worked out with Sherlock, and needs to be pushed by Marcus to finally reach out. But then Gregson is shot, and it might be too late to fix things. Solid season premiere though NYC is not a convincing London.
The Twilight Zone, “Nightmare as a Child” – Pretty obvious where this is going, but reasonably well done, and a rare instance where you can argue nothing supernatural happened.
Barney Miller, “Bugs” – While spraying for the kind of bug New Yorkers are used to, an exterminator finds two listening devices. Is Internal Affairs investigating the squad? How everyone deals with a sense of paranoia is quite interesting. (Great lines here: Harris compares things to 1984. Yemana, played by Jack Soo, who was interred during WWII, retorts, “or 1942.” I wonder how many people understood that.) And a roundup of sex workers nets a housewife who is so frustrated with her life that she takes to the street to see if anyone is more into her than her husband. Robert Costanzo plays the husband, and the body nearly matches the voice we would later hear as Harvey Bullock on BTAS.
In a Lonely Place – finally getting onto a bit of a noir streak now. This is another one I saw and loved years ago (2014, apparently) and have been meaning to revisit. I’m not sure I was quite as wowed by it second time around for whatever reason, although interestingly I did end up with a pretty different read on it than I did with my first viewing. I was kind of rooting for the central relationship first time through, despite everything – I saw it as an interesting study of a promising romance derailed by the pressures of a murder investigation. But with a little more world-weariness behind me, I could only see this as a take on toxic masculinity and the things people are allowed to get away with because of their celebrity / power. It’s pretty fascinating on that level but I’m not sure I’d quite have it in my top tier of noir, even if it’s still very good indeed.
As a film historian, IaLP has always struck me as a reflection of Hollywood at the time of the blacklist. Everyone knew who their friends were, and what they might be capable of doing, leaving one to wonder if a colleague was capable of either betraying their country or informing on their friends. This feels particularly acute when you look at Bogart’s initial public protests against HUAC (only to capitulate due to some contact with government and studio authority), Screenwriter Andrew Solt’s subsequent blacklisting and director Nicholas Ray’s unexplained avoidance of being named despite a leftist background in his theater days. I think your shifting feelings about what this film says is interesting, largely because it shows that its long lasting appeal rests in its perhaps unintended ability to remain relevant despite changes in the way Hollywood’s power structure is reframed in the broader culture over time. If the film stuck more closely to Dorothy Hughes’ book, it might even feel more relevant today.
Hacks S5E6 and S5E7 – The former is funny but kind of polemical, like the creators felt the need to comment on AI, even if it still ties into the obvious theme overall of what Deborah’s legacy will be. The best part was the B-plot of Jimmy and Kayla’s misadventure in Kalamazoo, MI (my sister’s alma mater) with a stand-up partying to cope with a hilariously dark secret. (I thought I recognized him and was right, it’s Sean Patton from English Teacher.) That and the reveal of Jimmy’s outfit when he has to get new clothes. Much stronger was the next episode, with the sheer farce of Ava and Deborah pretending to be gay so Deborah can get a Bob Mackie outfit from Cherry Jones’ character Kelly Kirkpatrick. The whole episode nails how with certain friendships, it can feel like you’re in a relationship even if you’re platonic, and Jones even gives really good advice to Ava about honesty.* Big, funny payoff when Deborah tries to come clean but the pair seem so intimate that Kelly and Monica simply don’t believe Deborah isn’t gay.
*I think a lot of shows make fun of lesbian couples and it was nice that Kelly and Monica actually appear to have a fairly happy, mature relationship.
What did we listen to?
Killing Is Our Business… And Business Is Good!, Megadeath
Time to move on to the fourth major thrash metal band, starring the guy who got kicked out of Metallica. This is the closest to any of the metal I’ve listened to that sounds like what you hear when a kid is listening to bad metal on a sitcom that sounds like noise to the parents.
Chocolate Starfish and the Hot Dog Flavoured Water, Limp Bizkit
Same as before – deliberately abrasive with few specific targets for the anger. There’s a parody of “Closer” by Nine Inch Nails which I find mildly amusing. What’s annoying though is that some of the songs get in the vicinity of good, but they’re ruined by Fred Durst’s voice, which is always inherently miserable and self-pitying. I find myself wondering why the fuck all their albums are so long; they could have cut the fat and even combined some song ideas into one more complex song.
Ess-Em, Ess-Em
One of the HOBOFOPO acts I saw. This is exactly my sort of shit – rock music holding hands with circus music – combined with a straightforward Australian accent. It bugs me a lot that Australian singers tend to sing in American accents, so I respond pretty well to lead singer SM pushing into outright bogan and finding the music in our accent – she’s very emotionally expressive. I also like that the lyrics are emotionally open (to the point that one of the songs has the C word in the refrain) while still being abstract enough to be relatable; one of the problems I have with punk lyrics is that the lyrics are often so specific that they either age literally like milk, or that I’m basically reading someone’s journal. Ess-Em’s stuff is closer to what I like, where it’s more about the emotion than the situation.
A friend of mine who now lives in Japan has just shared the poster for a show his band are playing with Ess-Em, in Kyoto, next week. A very enjoyable “I’ve never heard of this band, yet suddenly they are everywhere” coincidence.
1001 Albums, etc.
Green Day – Dookie: really enjoyed this one in my teens and I’m actually quite surprised how well it holds up now. Just a great bunch of catchy pop-punk songs.
Foo Fighters – Foo Fighters: solid and likeable, as a lo-fi home recording guy I kinda feel like this should be my favourite FF album… and maybe it is, actually – they released great singles later on but I’m not sure I’ve ever really been inspired to dig any deeper.
Garbage – Garbage: loved this one at the time, not sure it has aged all that well. The production is very locked in to this specific era but doesn’t give me quite the same nostalgic buzz as (e.g.) Dookie even though I listened to Garbage more and saw them live a couple of times. Still pretty enjoyable though, with some real high points.
Nightmares on Wax – Smoker’s Delight: enjoyably mellow jazzy trip-hop… none of my favourite ingredients but the end product is pleasant if not particularly memorable. I can definitely see the appeal in terms of chill-out music with a little more edge than most.
Tricky – Maxinquaye: this is at the grittier edge of trip-hop and I really enjoyed it. Kinda blew my mind that there’s a song here that uses the same sample as “Glory Box” by Portishead, you could make the argument that there was too much overlap in sounds within the genre but this does feel quite distinct despite that amusing coincidence.
Raekwon – Only Built 4 Cuban Linx…: this probably needs a closer listen to really get the full effect, as I played it in the car. But it had plenty of that early Wu-Tang punchiness that I enjoy from their first record.
Smashing Pumpkins – Mellon Collie and the Infinite Sadness: I find a little Billy Corgan goes a long way, but to his credit this sprawling two-hour album doesn’t really have much filler on it. The heavy stuff and the mellower, pop-leaning stuff works well across the board and my only real complaint is that his general air of pretentious angstiness gets a little old even if most of the songs do not.
Rocket From The Crypt – Scream, Dracula, Scream!: punchy rock & roll fun. I love the use of brass in rock music (ska-punk not so much) and it’s used to great effect here. I find the songs a little throwaway for the most part but it’s a good time.
The Chemical Brothers – Exit Planet Dust: I only really got on board with these guys from the next album, so this was mostly new to me. Definitely a more techno-leaning sound but with really nice, gritty drum sounds. I do generally prefer their stuff as they lean a bit more into pop production but this was enjoyable and I’m glad to have heard it.
—
Blank Check, Casino – made me really keen to rewatch Casino, which I guess means it was a good episode.
Screen Drafts, 90s Best Actress Oscar Winners – an interesting one, I didn’t expect Howard’s End to rank so highly and I feel I’ve fallen victim to the biases they describe against Merchant Ivory films feeling “like eating your vegetables” (which is a description I object to, vegetables rule, but I get the point). Anyway I should probably watch some of them.
Chicago 1997 revival Broadway cast, yes I went back to the source, sorta. Much more minimal orchestration compared to the movie which tracks, either way the score kicks ass. Amusingly Bruce Anthony Green sounds exactly like Jerry Orbach though I have not tried the 1975 version.
One Battle After Another while writing, even jazzier and more off kilter than I remembered with a real melancholy early on in the soundtrack.
Typical Cats – Typical Cats
This 2001 album had been on my radar and listening list forever, and I’m glad I finally got around to it. It’s a very laid-back boom bap album from a pre-9/11 world. The beats are solid — warm and jazzy —the punchlines land, and it avoids too much pollyannaism or pseudo-spiritualism, which can be pitfalls for conscious hip-hop.
It was the sonic hug I needed after listening to…
PISS- you made me / skin on linen
Don’t be repelled by the name. The debut from British Columbia quartet PISS has something to say and something to scream. This LP is equal parts spoken word and the sort of noise rock that scours the inside of your ears with chemical agent and steel wool. It levels righteous anger at systemic misogyny and gender-based violence. It’s a powerful, difficult listen, and legitimately heartening that it received too many write-ups for me to cover it in this space. I’m hopeful t will land in the running for a Juno Award.
Yeah that PISS album is quite something. I can’t say I’ll be playing it often but it’s powerful stuff, as is their live show!
There’s another song this year called “Penny in the Lake”?
Year of the Month updates:
We’ll be wrapping up 2026 with a look back at 2020! Here’s some lists of movies, albums, books, and TV to get you started.
Dec. 3rd: Cori Domschot: Underwater
Dec. 4th: Gillian Nelson: The Owl House
Dec. 6th: Tristan Nankervis: Mank
Dec. 11th: Gillian Nelson: Prop Culture
Dec. 18th: Joseph Finn: The Queen’s Gambit
Dec. 20th: Tristan Nankervis: Birds of Prey/Invisible Man
Dec. 25th: Gillian Nelson: COVID closings at the Disney parks
And there’s still time to write about anything from 1968 this month — here’s some lists of movies, albums, books, and TV to get you started.
TBD: Bridgett Taylor: Black Lizard
TBD: Cameron Ward: Horus, Prince of the Sun
TBD: Ruck Cohlchez: Astral Weeks
Nov. 19th: John Bruni: The Swimmer
Nov. 22nd: Tristan Nankervis: Slouching Towards Bethlehem
Nov. 26th: C.M. Crockford: The Lion in Winter