Watching Mark Robson’s horror-noir The Seventh Victim is a little like running a low-grade fever, and I say that as a compliment. It’s a wobbly, uncanny experience where everything is a tad off, because while it declines to outright bend our reality, it feels like it’s barely on speaking terms with conventional cinematic, narrative reality. Again and again, the film defies the notion that the story we’re watching has been consciously shaped. Characters drift in, taking on importance but no recognizable role. Decisions are made and unmade. Events and aspects that would seem crucial are handled in a peculiarly offhanded manner.
I’ll grant you that a young woman trying to find and protect her sister, who’s fleeing her own former satanic cult, is an unconventional story to begin with, but there would still be conventional ways to tell it. Robson—and producer Val Lewton, alongside screenwriters Charles O’Neal and DeWitt Bodeen—seemingly aren’t interested in even trying.
Kim Hunter makes her film debut here as Mary Gibson, the mild-mannered but iron-willed ingenue whose older sister, Jacqueline (Jean Brooks), has disappeared, leaving Mary’s school fees unpaid. Mary sets out to find her—and even this scene is odd, freighted with an unusually vivid one-off supporting character, a low-level school administration figure who tells Mary her own education stopped with similar abruptness, years ago, and warns her to never come back and take the job she’s been offered, lest she become trapped here too. The world of The Seventh Victim is full of monstrous (and queer, potentially) pitcher plants: environments that look like refuges until you drown in them.
Mary’s search for her sister is punctuated with more strangeness, with the most traditional figure—a hustling private eye who takes being warned off Jacqueline’s disappearance as all the more reason to dig into it—getting unceremoniously offloaded, and in an eerie, haunting way. Mary’s allies are questionable: her sister’s secret husband, Gregory Ward (Hugh Beaumont), who at first doesn’t admit to the role and then quickly falls in love with Mary; a well-meaning but oddly sinister psychiatrist, Dr. Louis Judd (Tom Conway); and a pining one-time poet, Jason Hoag (Erford Gage), who searches for meaning and love and finds neither. A semi-ally is Isabel Jewell’s Frances, who worked for Jacqueline and is now under the thumb of her magisterial replacement, Esther Redi (Mary Newton); Jewell makes Frances’s adoration of Jacqueline radiate from every pore. But Frances is still a Palladist, part of the same satanic cult Jacqueline joined and then betrayed, and the Palladists, though pacifists as a rule, find themselves obliged to demand Jacqueline’s death.
If you’re thinking this is all a little much for a 71-minute film, you’re right. The material is handled in a choppy, drifting way, and under-serving the apparent plot simply makes room for more ominous, darkly glittering detours, like a two-scene backstory subplot about Jason’s old flame and Judd’s fraught involvement with her.
What this is really about, though, is creeping dread and the doomy, free-floating paranoia of a nightmare, and that—in Jacqueline’s long slide to a bizarre death—is where The Seventh Victim shines. There are two unforgettable scenes here, and the movie smartly stacks them at the end. The last, in the literal final moments, is one I’ll save for any first-time viewers to encounter for themselves, but the first is a tour-de-force where the Palladists recapture Jacqueline. In a kind of grinding, disorientating hostage situation, they simply hold her in a luxurious parlor, with Brooks’s small frame and pale face, fringed with that dark line of bangs for an iconic look, swallowed up in furs and shadows and upholstery. The Palladists want to commit murder without getting their hands dirty, so they simply prod at her, hoping to wear her away like water wears away stone. Won’t she drink the poison before her? It won’t hurt. She knows this has to happen, doesn’t she? It’ll be better this way. She’s always found death enticing anyway. Drink, Jacqueline. Go ahead.
Jacqueline’s porcelain composure fractures for a moment, and she asks, wearily, if she can have a glass of water. There’s a darkly comic pause, and then the Palladists press on: there’s a drink right there, if only she’ll take it.
What The Seventh Victim understands is that the death you dazedly, halfway consent to is in some ways more unsettling than the one that forces itself upon you with sudden violence. Almost everything here happens gradually (or, if quickly, with so much lead-up missing that it feels like the development has surfaced, whale-like, out of some unseen ocean, which perversely carries the same sense of inevitability: you knew something had to be down there), and with a dreamlike sense of resignation. Of course this is where we were always going.
The Seventh Victim is streaming on HBO Now.
About the writer
Lauren James
Lauren James is a writer who wears many different hats (and pen names). She lives in Connecticut with her wife and two cats.
Lauren James’s ProfileTags for this article
More articles by Lauren James
Anthologized
You know what? This show has great episode titles.
Anthologized
A television milestone that's still bittersweet and powerful.
Streaming Shuffle
Hold, please.
Department of
Conversation
Oof, this sounds great. Del Toro talks about a similar sensation with Veronica Cartwright near the end of Alien where she’s almost consenting to her death, so in awe of this god-monster as she is.
Yes, I love that. There’s also something I’ve seen Howard David Ingham discuss re: folk horror, the “it was you they wanted all along” idea that recurs over and over again, and this has a little of that feeling too, only it’s like finding out that this is what you wanted all along. That sense of awed inevitability is very similar, I think.
What did we watch?
Serial Experiments Lain, Episode Ten, “Love”
One way I like this show is that I’m not entirely sure what it’s ultimately saying, and the reason I don’t know is because it hasn’t finished speaking yet. There’s so many shows and movies where I run out of things to talk about about two thirds of the way through because their statement has been made and you’re just waiting for the inevitable to play out. Not so here; Lain talks to God, or at least a creature claiming to be God, and ends up feeling more alienated than ever. The most shocking scene here is the one with her father, who essentially tells her she’s the only truly free person, and that he’s simply been looking after her until she realises this.
Much of the episode discusses whether or not Lain really needs a body or is simply a purely spiritual creature. Her material attachments – friends, family – have become more distant, until she feels disconnected from it all, and the Knights tell her she’s special before leaving (interesting bit of typical craft when they’re made two very distinct people after all this time, with one being ironic and amused and the other unsettled by Lain and telling her he loves her). The God tells Lain that her confident Wired persona is the real her. I don’t want to come to any conclusions yet. What will this say about Lain and the internet?
Elementary, “Gutshot” – Watson and Holmes return to NYC to investigate Gregson’s shooting. Holmes of course can’t set foot in the US without being arrested, so he’s here with a false passport, but that does not deter him for helping. Seems Gregson was looking into a missing persons case, and that missing person might tie into a domestic terrorism cell. The suspect is arrested, but with more riding on the line, Holmes takes drastic action and surrenders himself to the FBI. A clear shift in how we are doing things as this is not just a case of the week. But with just 13 episodes, cancellation pretty assured, and TV moving every more to serialization, it makes sense. Overall a good episode with a solid performance by Virginia Madsen as Gregson’s wife, who is suffering both from MS and her husband being near death.
Maverick, “Ghost Rider” – I honestly don’t understand why a woman pretending to be dead took Maverick for a wagon ride in the dark. The plot is a mess, but the performances are pretty solid. Stacy Keach Sr. shows up as a sheriff, and it’s not hard to find a resemblance in both face and voice to his recently deceased son. Look of rLuis Delgado among the extras. He would become a lifelong friend of Jim Garner’s, and be a semiregular on Rockford.
Barney Miller, “Corporation” – A corporate lawyer files a vandalism complaint, and soon enough the vandal is arrested. And he’s a window washer who’s done an elaborate and vulgar crossword puzzle of condemnation of the chemical company he’s offended by. We of course don’t see it, but we do see everyone reacted to it. Meanwhile, Wojo tries to help a “bag lady” after she’s mugged, and just cannot understand why anyone would chose to live that way. A good effort is made to allow her to keep her digniry and her agency.
Tokyo Drifter
Stylish as hell. Effectively a musical. Gorgeous colors and a whole lot of coolness. I can’t really respond to this emotionally because I am a story-and-characters person first and foremost and very basic in that way, but if I can’t entirely gel with this as a movie, I dig it as an art installation, if that makes sense. If this were bits and pieces playing in a museum, I’d be incredibly struck by it, and rightly so.
Poor Mutsuko (the woman who gets killed accidentally). It’s a little thing but Suzuki doesn’t pretend it’s all just part of the fun.
Reggie Dinkins – I usually violently disagree with Dennis Perkins’ (PERKINSSSSSSSS?) AVC reviews but I will probably agree with him, once I read the review, that this episode was slight, in part because I predicted one or two of the twists. Still Reggie Dinkins and thus very funny with a great final joke. “Second base really changes a man.” I believe in many of Ebert’s rules, but “Funny names are never funny” was wrong; see Les Purvis and Curtis Purvis. “I haven’t been this impressed with someone since Nicki Minaj straight up robbed me.”
Homicide: Life on the Street, episode 1 – my girlfriend has had the first two seasons on DVD for years but never taken the plunge, so we decided to check it out now that we’ve finished Seinfeld. We are stuck in the 90s. First impressions: damn, this looks rough. Loved the feeling of getting thrown in at the deep end though, so many characters and parallel investigations going on. Also, a lot more humour than I expected. Looking forward to more!
Twilight Zone, “Nightmare as a Child” – enjoyed this one quite a lot, it’s mysterious and full of tension throughout rather than really hinging on the twist (although of course it does have one). Also answers the question “can you build a man entirely out of red flags?” (yes). The young girl playing Markie is great.
Biggest double-take of my life at Red Flag Guy’s line about having had a crush on her.
Absolutely, yiiiiiikes.
Hell yeah The Seventh Victim! Absolutely love this one, the unusual storytelling only serves to increase the sense of mystery and dread. Probably my second favourite of the Val Lewton films, after Cat People.
Lewton is just so great, but yeah, this is really something special. The free-floating ominousness is sublime.
I need to finally watch this; it’s on a produced by Val Lewton set from Criterion that I have for I Walked with a Zombie. (And I recently watched the new documentary Black Zombie about the history of zombies on film and hoooooo boy is that an essential text.)
I have an old DVD set with all of them, plus a documentary about Lewton that I’ve never gotten around to checking out. I Walked With A Zombie would probably complete my Lewton Podium although I really like The Body Snatcher too! Thanks for the tip on Black Zombie, sounds really interesting.
Oh, I’ll definitely have to check out Black Zombie!
And I have that same Criterion set!
Black Zombie is on Kanopy if you have access.
Year of the Month updates:
We’ll be wrapping up 2026 with a look back at 2020! Here’s some lists of movies, albums, books, and TV to get you started.
Dec. 3rd: Cori Domschot: Underwater
Dec. 4th: Gillian Nelson: The Owl House
Dec. 6th: Tristan Nankervis: Mank
Dec. 11th: Gillian Nelson: Prop Culture
Dec. 18th: Joseph Finn: The Queen’s Gambit
Dec. 20th: Tristan Nankervis: Birds of Prey/Invisible Man
Dec. 25th: Gillian Nelson: COVID closings at the Disney parks
And there’s still time to write about anything from 1968 this month — here’s some lists of movies, albums, books, and TV to get you started.
TBD: Bridgett Taylor: Black Lizard
TBD: Cameron Ward: Horus, Prince of the Sun
TBD: Ruck Cohlchez: Astral Weeks
Nov. 19th: John Bruni: The Swimmer
Nov. 22nd: Tristan Nankervis: Slouching Towards Bethlehem
Nov. 26th: C.M. Crockford: The Lion in Winter
The trick with appreciating THE SEVENTH VICTIM is to succumb to the experience that it provides, rather than evaluating it as something that isn’t conforming to expectations. As you point out, the narrative focus of this film drifts from Lucy to Jacqueline, with numerous detours along the way. There is a European feel to this, which is emphasized by the rather strange lack of urgency in “resolving” the instigating incidents (kidnappings, and a murder) and questioning the issue of free will as a condition of independence. It’s more unsettling than scary in that lack of a conventional sense of closure and morality. BTW: You will love I WALKED WITH A ZOMBIE. It’s more of a precursor to WIDE SARGASSO SEA than NIGHT OF THE LIVING DEAD, and you get to experience the underrated Tom Conway once again break out his Costco George Sanders vibe.
I do love I Walked with a Zombie! Absolutely incredible, and that Wide Sargasso Sea comparison is perfect.
Yes, this definitely has a European sensibility: contemplative and hypnotic. It has some of the rhythms of poetry, too, especially in the way images and lines–“I saw her with you once, I saw her with you twice. Then I never saw her again”–come in and assume a weight on the basis of sheer effect, regardless of their meaning. Unstringing it from traditional narrative adds to the themes about free well, I think: cause and effect and choices don’t feel as relevant as the kind of uncovering of particular moments and images that stand out like landmarks.