Close Search Close

 

  • Comics
  • Theatre
  • Site News

A Correctly Structured Documentary? Nathan Fielder, Ricky Jay and manipulation

How and why the magicians do their tricks.

“I find the confidence game fascinating, the idea that intelligent people such as you or me can be deprived of our hard-earned money and self-respect by a correctly structured drama, in effect.” — David Mamet

There is a lot going on in You Can See Everything. Nathan Fielder and his crew (including co-director Lance Oppenheim) hang out with and in Fielder’s case wind up living with convicted fraudster Elizabeth Holmes and her husband Billy Evans for several weeks, collecting hours upon hours of footage that eventually become the 90 minutes or so of the documentary’s first half. And after Holmes goes to prison, Fielder continues to check in on Evans but eventually brings in Amanda Seyfried, who portrayed Holmes in a Hulu docudrama, to confide in and confront Evans and perform even more re-enactments of Fielder’s interactions with Holmes that have not been caught on camera.

And that first half has plenty of material on its own — Evans aggressively hanging dong, Holmes blithely lying about her crimes with intense innocuousness, Fielder interrogating her in both friendly and less-friendly-but-more-baffled-than-aggressive interviews. Fielder and Oppenheim’s cameras capture conversations and dialogues, and alternate between intense close-ups of speakers’ faces as they speak at and past each other and shots seemingly caught on the fly or through gaps in frames, suggesting eavesdropping or informality. Each person pushes their truth at each other in frustrating but compelling stalemate, which is not exactly the image rehabilitation Holmes and Evans signed up for when they requested Fielder to film them but is also plenty of screentime for their agenda (which includes getting back in the tech game) and their personalities. “Up until this point, You Can See Everything is an effective humanization of Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans. But it does not do much else,” Kelsey McKinney writes in Defector. “What are we to make of all of this? A much worse version of the movie ends there, with Holmes in prison and that question still front of mind.”

The second half answers the question of what we are to make of all this in the way that Johnny answers the same question in Airplane! — he can make a hat, a brooch, a pterodactyl. Fielder takes the footage of the first half and recontextualizes it, restages it, calls it into question. Fielder needs the first half to build on the second half, but also needs the viewer to ignore or disregard or be distracted away from that first half, and other aspects of the film that arise out of it, to go along with the second half’s meta structure. It’s a neat trick. Almost like sleight-of-hand.

***

There is a lot going on in Hustlers, Hoaxsters, Pranksters, Jokesters and Ricky Jay. The hourlong program, made for British television in 1995 and online in rather grainy video, profiles the many sides of Jay– historian, author, absolutely astonishing close-up magician, card sharp supreme — with each segment receiving a title card based on a quote said during the program. Director Rex Bloomstein doesn’t do anything too fancy and doesn’t need to, his straightforward style is fine for the talking heads and the interviews with Jay and it is essential for the clips we see of Jay in action. 

When talking about his interest in magic history Jay is erudite and passionate and Bloomstein makes sure to focus on the antique woodcuts and leaflets that fascinate Jay so. When performing an incredible combination of card trick and narrative — the structure of the act is based around the Lone Wolf And Cub movies, which Jay explicates and drops history anecdotes about as he lays out his cards, the patter not just essential to the act but the act itself — he is charming and gracious to the two people who make up his audience, and the camera almost never cuts but moves and probes, making sure to follow everything everyone, especially Jay, is doing and saying, so there is no confusion that what happens at the end has indeed happened, however impossible and magical it appears. And when Jay is performing tricks directly to the camera, often silently, there are no cuts at all, Jay’s eyes gazing at the viewer with something that is not arrogance, not in the pejoratively dominating sense, but with something beyond mere confidence. 

Confidence is a word with many shadings, though. At the end of the show, David Mamet — a longtime friend of Jay who has repeatedly cast him in his films — muses on con men and delivers the line epigraphed above. Cut to title card: A Correctly Structured Drama, which is also online as a standalone excerpt. And cut to a different Jay, one who still speaks with animated quickness but whose enthusiasm has curdled into annoyance and insistence. He’s talking with a man who he’s apparently never met before and trying to play a game — straight-up poker, each person gets five cards and whoever has the best hand wins. Jay gets last cut, the other person gets to deal. The guy, Bobby, is skeptical — are these cards marked? Where’d they come from, anyway? Jay, who has already shuffled and laid out ten cards, say he got them from a friend. “Would you play poker with a guy whose friend brought the deck?” Bobby asks, the jittery camera swinging back and forth but not cutting away, and Jay is contemptuous in response. “Would I? I’d play poker with anyone in the world.” 

Bobby keeps questioning why Jay gets last cut and Jay’s pushiness becomes aggravation: “I’m going to make up the rules, if you want to play you play, if you don’t you don’t, take out your money!” “Play or don’t play, I COULDN’T CARE LESS!” He is sick of Bobby’s shit and yells at the filmmakers, “GET THIS GUY OUT AND GET ME A GUY WHO WANTS TO PLAY, I WANT TO PLAY CARDS I DON’T WANT TO TALK!” Finally Bobby puts up money — he has to cadge $20 off the producers — and immediately cuts after Jay’s cut and Jay is volcanic: “GET THE NEXT GUY IN!” And one more cut, a hard one from the filmmakers, and Bobby is replaced by another guy shuffling the cards and looking like he wouldn’t dare take a cut.

The interaction between Jay and the very un-silent Bobby takes about three minutes, or nearly half of the eight-minute segment, and zero cards are even dealt, let alone played. But things move quickly after this. Jay lets this new mark not only deal but shuffle after each deal, after he’s put down $100 of course. And while the new guy deals himself a pair of 7s and a pair of Queens — the viewer may or may not have noticed that the ten cards Jay dealt out during the aborted hand with Bobby have remained as the cards in play — Jay gets three 9s. Go home, pal. The next man up gets the opportunity to not just deal, but to spread the cards out on the table and select whatever cards he wants, and he also winds up with a pair of 7s and a pair of Queens. “It looks like you win, doesn’t it?” Jay says, before flipping over three 9s. “Except you don’t.” Jay has been more polite to these guys, who after all are doing everything he says, than he was to Bobby, but he’s still brusque and pushy and dismissive once he’s got their money. In the last hand, all the previous players (including Bobby!) are at the table trying to help out the final sucker, who is showing the roving (but not cutting) camera the cards in the deck as they come up. Jay has given him the power to pick and choose each card — keep it, or deal it to him? (A very astute viewer might notice this scene begins with two cards already dealt.) The final guy asks his pals what to do with each card and they give him advice that is not just bad but meaningless, because while he has two Queens Jay has a pair of 7s and a pair of 9s. “You lose, I’m out of here.”

If you watch the cards closely as they are flipped over at the end of every game, you can see the ones that are in play here — three Queens, three 9s, three 7s, and one 8 — and that reveals the mechanism of the con, the math of how whoever gets that lone 8 will always have the worse hand. Someone would have to watch much more closely than I ever could to catch how Jay ensures the mark always gets the 8, some cardplayers do a good job breaking down the possibilities here, but Jay’s performance here — so different than how he acts elsewhere in the show — means that I and the people sitting down across from him are looking away from the cards, looking at him instead. Which is where he wants us to look. And while the con is purely extractive, you get the sense Jay is not performing his role in the sense of making something up out of whole cloth. Bobby really is annoying and Jay uses that and makes him look like a fool, a fucking dunce who can’t just play some fucking cards, a guy who absorbs all the furious disdain of the pro for the amateur. Bobby is also the only guy who doesn’t lose any money.

What this drama is built around is not a five-act structure but inverted variations on a theme. Bobby’s frustration of the con sets the boundaries, what will and will not be allowed, while surreptitiously creating the actual dynamic — this is where Jay produces the cards that he’ll use on the rest of the marks, who never question the ten cards in play. And it creates the emotional counterpoint, the embarrassment that the marks want to avoid, the embarrassment Jay gooses with his aggressive demeanor. Jay makes himself an antagonist and in doing so makes his marks the protagonists, if only in their own mind. Heroes of the drama. People who can act of their own free will and maybe be victorious, because as Jay tells them: “I’m going to give you every opportunity to win.”   

***

“You can see everything,” Holmes tells Fielder in YCSE’s first half. But what he’s seen — and what he and Oppenheim have shown us — is still unclear. So Fielder creates more for us to see, and to do so he relies on one of the magician’s most reliable gambits: pulling a beautiful woman out of the audience to help him with his trick. Amanda Seyfried becomes Fielder’s confidant and conspirator and collaborator while bringing her own unique perspective as past portrayer of Holmes, a creator of what she uneasily refers to as a fictional character that is based on a real life person (depicting Seyfried as a real life person and not a construct created within and by the movie is the filmmakers’ most successful sleight of hand). She lets Fielder interrogate that first half’s baseline through re-enactment and dialogue, as in conversation, rather than more obtrusive techniques like voiceover. But unlike in Jay’s manipulations, it’s easier to see the cards Fielder is not playing.

A large part of the second half of the movie revolves around Fielder and Seyfried’s investigation — obsession? — with what Holmes knew about compensation for being the subject of the documentary. Holmes denies receiving any financial reward to Fielder’s face during that first half and there’s no reason to assume otherwise — until Fielder begins talking to Seyfried, revealing that despite general practice to not pay documentary subjects, he did agree to some form of compensation. Fielder relates how Holmes and Evans set up a meeting with Fielder, Oppenheim and some A24 execs before filming began and once Holmes left the room, Evans started playing hardball and demanding money until the filmmakers reluctantly agreed to give him a piece of the profits. Unlike subsequent interactions between filmmakers and subjects, this meeting was not filmed at all. But with Seyfried’s eager participation, it can be re-enacted (with Seyfried standing in for Holmes and actor Christopher Abbott for Evans) and pored over. It’s important to understand this, Fielder says. He’s seen everything and still can’t decide if Holmes is a fabulist or a naif. But if she knew about this payment and told him otherwise, she’d be “the most manipulative person that’s ever lived.” To determine this, he and Seyfried’s re-enactment can analyzed as though it were real, in the absence of any other reality. 

But there is reality here. If A24 agreed to a payment then there almost certainly was a piece of paper laying out exactly what that payment was and who was getting it. It would be very easy to consult that piece of paper and see who is getting paid and how. Despite how objectionable this payment is, Fielder never mentions the specific money or percentage involved, and he does not mention this agreement as a concrete thing, even to dismiss it as something that can’t be consulted for legal reasons. And he also doesn’t interrogate how Holmes’ might have a very straightforward reason for denying compensation, considering that money that accrues to her is tied up in restitution to her victims. Lying for financial gain, the very thing Holmes goes to prison for, is not considered. Instead, Fielder creates a drama of speculation around a very easily answerable and yet ignored question. 

And this sets up a similar dynamic later on. After Holmes is imprisoned Fielder asks her, via letter, to call him in a hotel room on a certain day. Before that happens through, Evans calls Fielder and tells him he can’t record the conversation. This would seem to contradict an earlier scene in the film where Holmes is recorded calling her family (and Fielder and Seyfried), in any case this is Evans speaking and he may or may not be full of shit. But the filmmakers do not investigate (or if they do, I don’t believe they show) if there are any new restrictions on Holmes or the legality of those restrictions if they exist. The truth of Evans’ statement would be easy to determine, not doing so is a choice that Fielder is concealing. He’s doing so to provide the impetus for the re-enactment to proceed and to continue developing the themes and motifs of the second half, but once again an unspoken truth is presented as an unknowable one.

***

A Correctly Structured Drama is less than ten minutes long, You Can See Everything pushes three hours. If nothing else, three hours of sustained belligerence on the level Jay displays in Drama would likely have killed him long before his death in 2018. And three hours of a con like this would not work anyway, the mark must be bamboozled and overwhelmed in a pressurized period. Fielder operates differently, he is made for longer hauls. He builds dramas out of questions and answers, he asks the former and lets his subjects — perhaps it is not accurate to call them marks — spin out the latter for him to question again. Fielder does channel Jay at one point, though. In the movie’s first half, during one of the many circular and frustrating dialogues between Fielder and Holmes, Evans (as he often does) steps in to control the conversation. “I know how you feel,” Evans soothes at Fielder, who appears annoyed at the intrusion on both filmmaking and philosophical levels. He immediately snaps back: “No you don’t.”

Rebutting Evans’ blithe assurance of commonality is the overarching topic of You Can See Everything, from ironic title on down. How do you know what is in someone else’s head? How do you even know what is in your own? How you, yourself, feel? If Jay’s drama needs to be constrained to be effective, Fielder’s needs to expand into a narrative web of complex threads over an extended period of time for viewers — perhaps it is not accurate to call them marks — to grapple with them, or to feel as though they are able to grapple with them. And that can lead to questions of their own. Jay throws the questioning Bobby out of the game, if my skepticism above is Bobby-esque Fielder has created the space for it. I think the film wants to probe ideas of truth and certainty, but sometimes simple truths do exist and ignoring those to bolster an argument for unknowability undermines that argument.

At the end of Drama, Jay storms out of the room and his suckers bemusedly try to figure out what his deal was (“Does he need money that badly?” one asks). They seem to understand something went awry but can’t figure out how they, with all the advantages and choices they had, were fleeced. In contrast, the couple who participate in that Lone Wolf and Cub trick are awed, the woman in particular. “I made the choices, [we] made the choices,” she marvels, trying to understand how Jay found a card without touching it. “It makes you wonder if things are as they appear to be.” The two segments have nothing in common tonally but both lead the participants, and by extension the viewer, to a conclusion that is impossible. We may understand that Jay is concealing a con, but understanding intellectually is not the same as perceiving with our own eyes. Any sufficiently advanced trickery is indistinguishable from magic. Jay’s dramatic structure confounds even — especially! — when withholding information, while withholding (and remaking) information is the entire structure of Fielder and Oppenheim’s second act. 

Jay takes his marks for a hundred bucks a pop, Fielder and company got my $15 for a movie ticket, part of You Can See Everything’s massive (for a documentary) box office success. And I don’t feel cheated, I made my choice and paid for a movie and got one and no one held a gun to my head. But what I saw was mostly smoke and mirrors.