Close Search Close

 

  • Comics
  • Theatre
  • Site News

Year of the Month

Yours, Mine, and Ours and the Power of Staying

Looking at Yours, Mine, and Ours, marriage and the power of staying

Yours, Mine, and Ours (1968)

I want to start by letting people know that some of the things I’m going to talk about will not be true for everyone. I know that not all home situations are the best, and staying is not always the best option. We will strictly be talking about the healthy family dynamics displayed in the 1968 version of Yours, Mine, and Ours (Shavelson 1968). I ask that everyone remember this is 1968, and the movie focuses on two Catholic families becoming one after both spouses were widowed. Opportunities, medical options, and even how religion views situations have changed through the years. My article will be focusing on a long speech given towards the end of the movie, and I will be relating it to the everyday ins and outs of healthy relationships, and choosing to stay.

“I’ve got a message for Larry. You tell him this is what its all about [as he guides his wife through the house contractions 6 minutes apart]. This is the real happening. You want to know what love really is, take a look around you. Take a good look at your mother. Yes, now. It’s giving life that counts. Till you’re ready for it, all the rest is just a big fraud. All the crazy haircuts in the world won’t keep it turning. Life isn’t a love-in, it’s the dishes and the orthodontists, and the shoe repairman, and ground round instead of roast beef. And I’ll tell you something else; it isn’t going to bed with a man that proves you love him. It’s getting up in the morning and facing the drab, miserable, wonderful everyday world with him that counts.” Frank Beardsley (Henry Fonda 1:41:37-1:42:16)

As we look around the scene when Henry Fonda asks us to, we see the children pulling together to make sure this all goes as smoothly as possible. Mike Beardsley (Tim Matthieson) had immediately been asked to get the car out of the garage and warm it up. Tommy North Beardsley (Mitch Vogel) was asked to pack Helen North’s bag (Lucille Ball). Rosemary Beardsley (Nancy Roth) and Louise Beardsley (Suzanne Cupito) were asked to put pillows and blankets in the back of the car [since no children go with the adults, I am not sure why he asks them to do that]. This family has blended beautifully. Later in the movie all the children are adopted so that both parents have equal rights should one of them die. The youngest children were also woken up in the hullabaloo and are told to go back to bed. All of this to show that the family is working together to make sure everything goes smoothly.

When Mike gets downstairs, he found his sister Colleen North Beardsley (Jennifer Leak) with her shirt partially unbuttoned underneath her boyfriend Larry (Ben Murphy). Larry has been pushing Coleen for sex for a while. Mike immediately started punching Larry, causing Frank to have to intervene. He manages to ask Rusty Beardsley (Gil Rogers) to go get the car instead, while he keeps Larry and Mike from fighting as best he can with Mike getting some good hits in despite his Navy dad’s attempts to keep them apart. I wanted to highlight this interaction to show that Mike Beardsley is standing up for his sister Coleen North Beardsley. This is his soon-to-be-adopted sister and honestly one of the first interactions we see of the children bonding together. We are near the end of the film, and I counted four times there was positive sibling interactions between the two families, and all of them happen prior to the adoptions. While conflict between the siblings isn’t heavily portrayed, the idea that there have been hurdles is.

To get back to the speech that Henry gave, he is not only saying that their family coming together in times of strife is important, but also the fact they are doing this because their mother is pregnant. The real consequence of having sex, especially in the setting of this movie where contraceptive was not as readily available, and in a Catholic house not likely available at all, was a potential pregnancy. I will commend the movie for not trying to discourage teenagers from having sex; why make a rule you know they won’t follow? Both Helen, in her observing Coleen and Larry’s early dating, and Frank in realizing he is breaking up a fight between Mike and Larry because of how Mike found Larry and Coleen, is handled very tastefully. She isn’t rebuked, she is informed. I hope I would be so cool if I found one of my children in such a situation (may it be years and years away *crosses fingers*). Something else highlighted in this scene is that Frank dated prior to his first wife (quote not shown but it happens in between the fight and the speech), and we know he dated at least one other woman before marrying Helen North, as the interaction of them running into each other during the date is shown in the film. During the time when Frank was getting ready to date again, his friend Darrell Harrison (Van Johnson whom you can also find in In The Good Old Summertime 1949), insinuates that he needs to get back into the habit of having sex. Indicating to me that he may not have been celibate prior to his first marriage, and he definitely seemed open to try dating and possible relations now. This goes to further demonstrate that these parents are trying to be real with their children. I’m not saying you can’t have sex, I’m saying you might end up pregnant and with Larry as the father (a fate I definitely wouldn’t want to face).

Henry goes on to say, “Life isn’t a love-in (I had to look this up, it’s a purposeful meeting to have sex), it’s the dishes, and the orthodontists, and the shoe repairman, and the ground round instead of roast beef.” These are the everyday choices that all families make when times are tough. You want to go on vacation? It probably starts with a budget. Most families today I would say need to know the bills are paid as rent increases, grocery bills increase, and gas prices soar. The movie illustrated Frank making these choices after Helen had brought up adopting the children. He mentions it is $250 per child to make that happen. She then lists a bunch of things they could start cutting back on to make it work. In response, Frank hands her the beer he had been planning to buy. He is with her and willing to make the sacrifices to make their families lives better. Now, this family is living in a fixer upper Victorian mansion. I say this because it has 7 bedrooms, that we know of, and 4 bathrooms. Mike as the oldest got a room to himself, with all the other children being split between 5 other rooms and Frank and Helen had a veritable suite. I saw a walk-in closet, and I don’t know if they share that bathroom with the other kids but a door to what could only be an attached bathroom exists. Looking carefully at their chart I’m thinking they prioritized it for themselves as I only saw, Red, Blue, and Green bathroom options for the kids. I say a fixer upper because they note the roof needed repair, and the plumbing wasn’t the most modern. This family was no stranger to making do. How they were housing and feeding all 20 of them is a miracle written off as the Naval Commissary. While I can say with personal experience that commissary prices are excellent, they are very close to Costco pricing. Instead of buying bulk to get the price, you are allowed smaller quantities. My food allergies have always caused my food bills to be higher than any one person should have to pay. To make matters worse, some of my allergies mean my son can’t eat food I’m having because of his allergies. They do not let us know if the grocery trip they show us is for two weeks (most military families get paid bi-monthly and both Frank and Helen work for the Navy). Things I don’t know about military pay include how dependents work with 18 children and how dependents work with 2 people in the military. After their marriage, does Helen claim 18 dependents and Frank as well? Or does Helen keep claiming her 8 and Frank his 10? You also see them buying the cheapest options of things, Wonder bread, peanut butter and jelly, oats, and milk, as well as other items that aren’t highlighted. They end up with a whopping bill of $126.63 for 4 heaping grocery carts of groceries. All of this illustrates Frank practices what he is telling Coleen. That you have to do the boring everyday stuff, and the scary bill stuff.

“And I’ll tell you something else; it isn’t going to bed with a man that proves you love him. It’s getting up in the morning and facing the drab, miserable, wonderful everyday world with him that counts.”

Anyone who has been married for more than a month knows the honeymoon ends. Reality sets back in. Sometimes that means you are blending families together, sometimes it means you are soon to welcome a first bundle of joy, and sometimes that means you may want a bundle and are putting it off, or can’t easily have one. Or maybe, your family is complete at 2. No matter what is happening, the bills have to get paid, the house needs to be cleaned, and you will keep waking up next to a person you said you would share the rest of your life with (according to traditional wedding vows). There are going to be days that your spouse and you fight. There are going to be days the kids don’t listen and you are at your wits’ end. There are going to be hard discussions about what is still able to happen during this terrible economic strain. In our home, this means waking up and choosing love. My husband said something beautiful to me once that he would keep choosing our family. He’s choosing the higher grocery bills to allow me to have meals that aren’t rice noodles and flavor packets, he’s choosing the king bed because our neurospicy children still aren’t sleeping through the night the majority of the time, he’s choosing to love someone who is still healing from CPTSD from a first marriage and a rape. Waking up and choosing to stay together is something all families must face at one point or another. The glamour of the love you first felt will fade. The chores and the bills will feel overwhelming. The amazing thing about Yours, Mine, and Ours isn’t just that two large families blended successfully. It is also that two widowers of large families found each other. That they had been faithful in their previous marriages and both deeply loved and felt the loss of their own spouses. That they both knew the work of being married to the Navy first and to each other second. They knew the power of choosing to keep going, and they did.