The Friday Article Roundup
An excitable look at the best pop culture writing of the week.
This week, you will kick around:
Send articles throughout the next week to magpiesmedia [at] gmail, post articles from the past week below for discussion and Have a Happy Friday!
For Indiewire, Vikram Murthi says David O. Russell’s new John Madden biopic can’t get into the end zone:
Part of the problem is that Madden, while being an American institution and a legendary NFL coach, isnโt really suited to be the subject of a biopic, largely because the details of his life are fairly free of drama or intrigue. Heโs the kind of figure who should be the lead of a Saturday-morning cartoon where he helps kids solve mysteries using the power of his football mind. Rather than impose a zany plot onto his life or make up outlandish shit for entertainment purposes, which heโs known to do, Russell dutifully relates the major events in his life.
Lincoln Michel considers the state of literature, and makes an anti-state case:
I do not think that the state of literature, to the degree we can measure it, remains flat. Some eras are better or worse. However, a clearer truth is that the state of literature (like any art form) is always in flux with some areas waxing and others waning. The hippie boom of rock music may have faded into vapid guitar noodling and disco by the late 70s / early 80s, but thatโs the same time we saw the rise of punk and hip-hop. The era of maximalist systems novels might have fallen out of fashion by the mid-00s, but that was also the rise of autofiction. Prestige TV dramas peaked in the 00s, but absurdist comedy shows are better today. So on and so forth.
At her substack, Justine Smith pays tribute to the women who dominate Russ Meyer’s movies:
The image of Raven De La Croix, โour doe-eyed fucking machineโ leaning over a wooden headboard in Up!, writhing as she sits on the sheriffโs face, has to be one of my favourite images in the 1970s American cinema. Her eyes rolling languorously and her Mae-West affect are intercut with the images of her soft belly and bush, the sheriffโs broken glasses and his upturned feet: itโs stupidly sexy. Thereโs nothing desperate or urgent about her desire; itโs grounded and essential. Perhaps born out of [Meyer’s] early naturalist films, there was always something primal and accepting in his filmโs treatment of sex. It also has an adolescent playfulness that has an infectiously tantalizing quality.
Leor Galil writes a thorough obituary for the late local punk and labor advocate Cornelio “Corny” Ramirez for the Chicago Reader:
Corny learned about HVAC maintenance as a student at Chicago Vocational High School, and [his daughter] Xochitl says that even before then heโd been following an uncle on the job to learn the trade. โHis music was an opportunity for him to speak about the injustices that he felt and the injustices that he saw in the world,โ she says. Dead Steelmill played benefits for labor groups and joined the Save Our Jobs committee, formed in 1980 by former Wisconsin Steel laborer Frank Lumpkin. Lumpkin became a well-known fighter for civil rights and worker powerโand a fan of Dead Steelmill.
And at Episodic Medium, Donna Bowman describes her time as a contestant on Jeopardy!:
Turns out I underestimated the number of venues in which I became a โmicrocelebrity,โ in the words of an online acquaintance. Church, school, Discord groups, fellow critics and religion scholarsโthose I anticipated. But my โhost chatโ anecdote unlocked another group Iโd never even thought of: Splatoon people. I talked to Ken about playing competitive Splatoon and gave a shoutout to my team Death Crab for Cutie. My thought was โIโll tell my teammates that theyโre going to get mentioned on national syndicated television, theyโll get such a kick out of it.โ I completely forgot (largely from having left Twitter years ago) that a whole subculture of comp Splatoon folks exists on social media. Suddenly people were passing me screenshots of Splatoon people yelling online WHO IS THIS LADY THEOLOGIAN WHO PLAYS COMP SPLATOON? and celebrating that their niche hobby escaped containment. (They’ve all been very, very nice.)
Tags for this article
More articles by Dave Shutton
How and why the magicians do their tricks.
The Friday Article Roundup
The best and most righteous pop culture writing of the week.
The Friday Article Roundup
Cooped up with the best pop culture writing of the week.
The Friday Article Roundup
You wouldn't keep out the best pop culture writing of the week, would you?
The Friday Article Roundup
From the hub of the universe, the best pop culture writing of the week
Department of
Conversation
What did we watch?
Babylon 5, Season Five, Episode Twenty-Two, โSleeping In Lightโ
Well that sucked. I was noticing the last half of the season was making as much as it could out of less and less material, and this is, like the one airing before it, making nothing out of nothing. I can handle a show ending with a victory lap, but this is a victory lap entirely about Sheridan, which feels a bit much – my favourite part is when Vir reflects on Londo, who alongside GโKar and Lennier, died long before the episode is set (twenty years after the events of season four). Otherwise, itโs everyone going โMan, isnโt it sad that Sheridan is going to die tomorrow?โ. Actually, Iโll give it up for the sequence where Sheridan realises both he and the station will โdieโ at the same time, as itโs become entirely redundant and going to be scuttled; Zach Allen gets a line that feels like a meta statement from Straczynski (“We did everything we said we were going to. No one can take that away from us.”), which itself ties together Sheridan and the overall project of the show better. Still, I think โThe Deconstruction of Fallen Starsโ made a better ending for the show.
So thatโs Babylon 5. Ultimately, I think itโs a rare Three Star Show where, rather than being extremely watchable because each episode is slick and compelling whilst having little to no larger story (like Law & Order or Bobโs Burgers), each episode is actually kind of a slog but fits into a larger, very compelling story and set of ideas and themes. I intend to revisit it at some point in order to steal ideas from it for my tabletop gaming world, and then Iโll probably never go back to it, but I do think the journey was ultimately worth it, even season five (which had some very good individual episodes and ideas amongst the chaff).
Consistently the one thing it was best at was solutions that far exceeded the mystery of the setup; even from the first season, when a mystery was explained, I was hooting and hollering with joy, and indeed I was still doing so with revelations in season five. This is where the long-term planning really helped, I think – Straczynski could consistently set my expectations and then exceed them because he knew exactly where he was going anyway. The mythology has some holes in it – like the Minbari having basically nothing beyond woo-woo mysticism at their core – but so many elements of this world are very cool.
A close second was that there were quite a few characters I really did care about. Lennier will always be my main man, a devout loyalist above and beyond (I watched a very funny interview where Bill Mumy complains that his ending takes him out of the story โlike a wimpโ by betraying this). But a close second is actually Kosh, who is a very strange and interesting twist on the cosmic pompous alien, where that pomposity is a partly a cover for insecurity (a very Neon Genesis Evangelion idea). I actually found myself really missing Kosh in the second half of the show because his perspective was so interesting.
Londo and especially GโKar really carried the show for me too; this is where we go down a bit, because their arcs were thoroughly predictable, but were delivered with enough sincerity and panache that I enjoyed myself. GโKar does complicate his development a bit in how he reveals himself as a fundamentally religious figure driven by a desire to represent an ideal (the one thing that does actually unite this with Deep Space Nine in terms of themes).
There are two weak aspects to B5. The first is the dialogue; itโs fundamentally the work of a white man who has never once, in his life, been told to shut the fuck up. Straczynski will never use three words when ten will do, often trampling all over his own ideas in his excitement to express them. The other, oddly enough, is the showโs perspective. Itโs a thoroughly liberal (as in not leftist) show, and sometimes that really is interesting – like in the way it reforms and rebuilds institutions, as well as building new ones – whilst other times, it comes off more naive than competitor Star Trek due to its ostensibly grittier and less ideologically-driven setup.
Whilst the showโs grasp of mystery-solution is fantastic, its grasp of cause-and-effect is a bit murkier, like the thoroughly embarrassing ending it creates for the Shadow War (as compared to the thoroughly badass ending of the Earth Civil War). I often found it hard to care about the narrative drive of the story because I knew it was basically working to get to a particular ending as opposed to the messier and more naturalistic structure I tend to like. Philosophically, I part with the series in that it feels like it thinks the action itself is the hard work and fun part – this is where the seriesโs most rah-rah enthusiasm lies – when I tend to be more interested in what comes after the main work.
Next week, Iโm gonna start watching movies every Friday. I feel like I donโt watch enough movies anymore.
I need to get back to this. My regular TV viewing got badly thrown out of whack when I moved (about a month ago), and it hasn’t gotten back on track yet for various and sundry reasons.
I petition to have us all pelt you with suggestions of movies we’d like to see you reactions to.
“Itโs a thoroughly liberal (as in not leftist) show, and sometimes that really is interesting โ like in the way it reforms and rebuilds institutions, as well as building new ones โ whilst other times, it comes off more naive than competitor Star Trek due to its ostensibly grittier and less ideologically-driven setup.”
This is a problem of execution more than concept to me — if the show’s setting is a purposefully constructed institution, it’s probably not going to come down against institutions and that’s fine. When it doesn’t think things through — the much-discussed ‘why are there slums on the space station’ issue, for example — then it gets wonky, and while humans are obviously the focus it can cede things to that perspective too much at times. But in the end, the show’s biggest problem is a simple one: NOT ENOUGH MANTIS GUY
How to Murder Your Wife – Dear lord, this is misogynistic crap. And yet not actually a terrible movie? Jack Lemmon is a cartoonist and confirmed bachelor who gets drunk and marries an Italian beauty contest participant. She adores him to bits, and serves to inspire his newest comic strip, but he gets tired of her, and is bizarrely accused of murdering her. The film’s hideous attitudes about women and marriage are hard to take, but it’s the last set piece, with Lemmon convincing a courtroom full of men that it’s okay to want to kill your wife, is about as bad as you can get. And yet this is in some weird way an useful time capsule of what sexism was like in 1965, when what the men cannot stand is now held up as the basis of the perfect Tradwife lifestyle. (Well, maybe with less “henpecking,” which Lemmon’s wife does not do.) Lemmon is pretty good being insufferable, and Virna Lisi is remarkably good as the nameless woman (she is only called “Mrs. Ford,” never getting a first name). Richard Quine’s directing is passably good, and George Axelrod’s script is, well, crap. (He did the script for The Manchurian Candidate. Clearly, it helps to have been adapting a good book.)
Elementary, “Red Light, Green Light” – A van crashes into a truck, and explodes. Terrorists? Nope. Drug dealers stealing gasoline to make extra money. But it turns out the crash is not about the van but the truck, and a scheme to screw up a construction firm’s bids. By hacking into NYC’s traffic lights. The set up is more interesting than the resolution, though it does bring up questions of how safe the traffic grid is. Cool to see the show use the actual NYC DOT logos we see all over the place. Meanwhile, Gregson is awake again and helping with the case, and the man who shot Gregson is getting worried and wants to deal with Joan.
The Lowdown — Hawke is the lead but the first season spent a fair amount of time with his antagonists doing their antagonist stuff in a very Elmore Leonard-ish fashion, and one character ultimately became an interesting bridge between the two at the end. This season has the antagonists in more complicated relationships and this is driving the best bits, Clifton Collins Jr. has been lurking in the background for a while and gets a fantastic scene here, and I’m wondering if another bridge will be built in the final episode. Still very good and the Leonard vibes remain strong, there is a nice bit involving a character who on the whole is stupid and fucking up but he is smart enough to see something bad coming (after yet another fuckup) and acts accordingly — no easy outs.
Old Always Sunnys — poking around the last four-five seasons. I remember laughing very hard and very uneasily at Dennis in the suburbs and in particular him driving, that hit a bit too close to home, and Dennis Takes A Mental Health Day is an entire episode of this. But worse! The person in traffic has no one to blame but themselves, as the engineers say you are not in traffic you ARE traffic, but here all inconveniences are roadblocks thrown up on previously clear streets. I demand blood.
The Autopsy Of Jane Doe — hey, blood! This is quite good and like most horror mysteries is best in the beginning as things are slowly revealed. Andrรฉ รvredal later made the wack-ass Last Voyage Of The Demeter and it’s a great case of a guy only being able to do so much with a shit script, รvredal handled the enclosed area of the ship well and was stuck with a butt story — here he’s in a similarly enclosed space and navigates it with generally unshowy finesse (several jump scares are made in the edit and how a new object appears in the screen as opposed to the object itself being “scary,” very nicely done). And there are actual characters here, the backstory is less important as revelation as it is foundation for Cox and Hirsch to build on for their current actions and they’re very good, especially when those actions take a turn for the practical relatively early on, no dumb behavior here. But of course the star is Olwen Kelly, who doesn’t move the whole damn film but still acts as a presence, รvredal leaves her mouth slightly open for much of the movie and shoots down at her in a way that suggests violation, especially as these dudes are literally ripping her open, and this sets the tone for all the boogedy boogedy stuff later on. This turns out to be an interesting companion piece to Lords of Salem*, which is more overtly feminist in many ways (its female lead walks and talks, for one thing) but doesn’t hit as hard in terms of fate and action. And it occurs to me it is also a companion piece to a certain Laika film, which does. Anyway, good stuff I’m glad I caught up with.
Fuck yeah, The Autopsy of Jane Doe! “Let the sun shine in…” I’m a big champion of this, as I feel like it doesn’t get nearly enough attention: chilling, well-structured, and clever. I was referencing it recently when I rewatched The Conjuring, which I like a lot but which annoys me with its unremarked-upon assumption of the validity of witch trials; this does it right, with Matthew Hopkins’s ilk spawning supernatural Godzillas, making monsters out of what was only natural before.
I’m not entirely sure how old Jane made it from one Commonwealth to another (let alone that particular basement) but that isn’t really important. But it does lead to some unpleasant implications — if we “know” the history in question then it seems like she didn’t get a lot done against the people who did this to her. Hirsch and Cox (and whoever’s next up, the sheriff ordering this insane shit out of his county is a dark little laugh at the end) are really fucked here, this is indebted to The Ring (man does Cox have a rough go with these!) in its reversal of the unquiet dead trope but Samara really feels out of nowhere, Jane being set in motion is grimmer.
Tales From The Crypt – “The New Arrival” – RIP Peter Medak who fills this episode with a lot of fun shots and visual tricks, like the POV from a victim seeing a whirling ceiling fan far too late. David Warner, at peak arrogance, plays a child psychologist turned talk radio host (it is the 90’s)* who makes a house call to a frequent caller with her own problem child. This is a pretty nasty satire of a certain kind of doctor/personality type who thinks every problem can be handled rationally and Warner is of course cast perfectly.
*Plus a shock jock is played by Robert Patrick, who seems like he’d be better in a different episode, maybe as a desperate creep.
I’m a simple person who sees a David Warner mention and provides an upvote.
As you should!
What did we read?
Lenin: A Biography, Robert Service
The Bolsheviks start seizing power. They kind of declare victory before it’s actually happened, which characterizes my understanding of Soviet Russia. They were, depending on your point of view (and how much you value human life), either amateur blunderers stumbling through or incredibly ambitious and industrious and willing to endure failure after failure until they got to success. Lenin in particular is in his element, no longer having to think about criticism at all.
What’s interesting is that he’s setting up the Terror without openly making it obvious – the institutions that make it possible, with the unlimited power and no accountability that comes with it, but before they’re given real power.
A Divided Duty by Seanan McGuire – The 20th October Daye book, and while part of me thinks that my longtime friend should get to the novel or novels where Toby and Tybalt finally confront all their enemies, the series has settled into a good place the last five books, and this one lowers the stakes a bit and addresses things that were first introduced in the third book of the series. There is also a very interesting mix and match that has Toby teaming with a different sidekick than usual and that might be intended to change things up for good at some point. Assuming that Seanan doesn’t end the series.
Retroactive write-up:
Blackwater, by Michael McDowell
It’s a Southern Gothic family saga with river monsters, extremely gnarly murders, faux-decorous dramedy-of-manners power struggles, and it’s 800+ pages (originally published as six novellas), and everyone should read it if this sounds remotely good to them, because this is The Shit. (Dave-coded, perhaps?) McDowell is one of my favorite horror writers–both an astute and empathetic observer of the human condition and absolutely, acidically ruthless–and this is probably his best work. We follow the Caskeys, a genteelly wealthy Southern family in a small town called Perdido in the early twentieth century, and one of them marries Eleanor, a woman who is secretly a river monster who sometimes kills and eats people in an utterly amoral manner (McDowell truly does not care what one thinks about this: you get the occasional murder you can feel good about, but Eleanor also brutally chows down on some innocent children, including a young Black boy in the family’s service and an intellectually disabled child whose parents are the Caskeys’ business competition–their grief will help the Caskeys buy up more property!). It’s all marriages (including one lesbian one, effectively) and parent-child relationships and making money and town perception and the business of running a mill and the feeling of the passage of time, punctuated with some incredibly horrific standout scenes involving monsters or ghosts.
I agree with the Nathan Ballingrud introduction that says this could do more with its Black characters than it does, but it’s still better on that front than most horror of its era, and actually, one of the most unsettling aspects for me is Eleanor effectively co-opting a young Black girl by ostensibly championing her.
Powerful, unusual, deeply engaging stuff. I was sorry to finish it.
“one of them marries Eleanor, a woman who is secretly a river monster who sometimes kills and eats people in an utterly amoral manner” hmm this is making a pretty good case for that movie Simon watched! But this sounds great, and the linked novella structure seems very promising — horror is generally better shorter, right?
She’s actually quite a good wife and mother! (Though her actions do rebound on her husband to his misfortune at various points.)
I’d be really curious to reread this at some point more as a series of novellas than as one sprawling novel–the novellas often get a startling act of horror near the end, so pacing them to emphasize that would be cool and probably emphasize the more gruesome bits.
Everybody Dies, by Lawrence Block — back on my Matt Scudder bullshit! And as the title indicates, there is a lot of killing here, the story revolves around someone attacking Scudder’s friend Mick Ballou, an Irish gangster who runs a bar and is involved in lots of shady shit and who has killed people in the past, their relationship is a pillar of the series and it’s part of the complicated morality Scudder has. This is tied to his alcoholism and AA sobriety, the idea of “one day at a time” is reconfigured into “not today,” an even narrower window of how to live, even as Scudder has a normal life with his wife and friends. At one point and in self-defense Scudder shoots a guy who he has every reason to kill, the wound will be mortal without any further action and Scudder walks away (and has his own severely wounded friend to focus on), and later reasons that he didn’t want to outright murder the guy but subconsciously put himself in a position where death was likely. The book lets this stuff sit, and then climaxes with a ton of ownage that doesn’t erase what happened on the way there. One of the best in the series.
The Dollhouse Murders, by Betty Ren Wright — revisiting an old kids’ book with an eye toward dropping it on the nephews, it’s not a Dell Yearling book but is in that mode and are these even being published anymore, the late elementary school one-offs? Anyway, the protagonist is a 12-year-old girl who goes to live with her aunt in the old family house as a way of getting some time away from her nuclear family, in particular her developmentally disabled sister. This is not as cruel as it sounds, Wright is writing in the early 80s but to my mind is sensitive to the sister and is working on a theme of unspoken trauma and regret that is conveyed here by the two sisters being unable to develop their own independence. And is conveyed in the rest of the book by the giant dollhouse our hero finds in the attic of the house, a dollhouse that is the house in miniature and has dolls that re-enact the murders of her grandparents that took place in the house decades ago (a murder that her aunt, who had a strained relationship with her parents at the time, has her own trauma over). This is a great conceit and Wright does fine work with it, creepy but not King-level fear, and perhaps the spirit moving these dolls is trying to tell her something? Wright is very emotionally astute and crafts a good supernatural mystery, what this feels like more than anything is what Mike Flanagan is trying and failing to do with his bloated bullshit. Once again, the youth authors of the past triumph over the hacks of the present.
We called these middle-grade novels or chapter books when I was in library school, but that was over ten years ago now, so I’m not sure if that’s still current. But I was delighted when studying the children’s librarianship side of things that people were still doing some pretty solid children’s horror: Joseph Bruchac’s Skeleton Man, from 2001, might be worth trying with your nephews. And you’ll notice my hip, up-to-date reference is still from 20+ years ago, but it was past my own nostalgia period, at least, and I still enjoyed it when I came to it for the first time!
I need to make another trip to the Book Barn in Niantic and scour it for some Scudder novels.
“Chapter books” is what I remember too, I thought it was a more informal categorization. I will look for Skeleton Man! My vague sense now is that these books seem more series-focused but I could be wrong. Dollhouse Murders is an Apple Paperback book and in trying to think of similar titles I recalled Help, I’m A Prisoner In The Library by Eth Clifford and what do you know, it’s an Apple too:
https://d3525k1ryd2155.cloudfront.net/h/930/061/1465061930.0.x.jpg
And while this wasn’t a series, the protagonists return in the extremely boss titled/covered Just Tell Me When We’re Dead!
https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcS09uhMiwawhH42FrXjGQQ-wZWJAmo7x6gct25WMDLK7REcz_nPW9VFet0&s=10
A lot of different stuff, so a brief recap: Shadow Over Innsmouth – a good if uneven compilation of Lovecraft/Innsmouth mythos stories; Crone by Keith Rosson, Not Optional especially if you like revenge, stories about cruel violence, and brutal ownage, the last chunk of the book is devastating; The Verge by Patrick Wyman which is a chronicle, seemingly, of the creation of the modern state amidst the New World “discoveries”/conquests.
the road. This is kinda relentless and famously bleak. Reading this after its imagery has been fully absorbed into American pop culture probably deprives it of some of its impact (I kept getting last of us vibes. McCarthy shamelessly ripped off druckman). But stylistically and structurally the story keeps moving down the road looking for the next story beat so even though thereโs not actually much plot it zips along. I am not 100% clear what sort of nuclear apocalypse leaves any human survivors but no trees or birds or fish. I donโt think a post-apocalyptic nuclear hellscape would really be as bad as Cormac does.
Year of the Month updates:
We’ll be wrapping up 2026 with a look back at 2020! Here’s some lists of movies, albums, books, and TV to get you started.
Dec. 3rd: Cori Domschot: Underwater
Dec. 4th: Gillian Nelson: The Owl House
Dec. 6th: Tristan Nankervis: Mank
Dec. 11th: Gillian Nelson: Prop Culture
Dec. 17th: John Bruni: Fear of Death
Dec. 18th: Joseph Finn: The Queenโs Gambit
Dec. 20th: Tristan Nankervis: Birds of Prey/Invisible Man
Dec. 25th: Gillian Nelson: COVID closings at the Disney parks
And there’s still time to write about anything from 1968 this month โ here’s some lists of movies, albums, books, and TV to get you started.
TBD: Bridgett Taylor: Black Lizard
TBD: Cameron Ward: Horus, Prince of the Sun
TBD: Ruck Cohlchez: Astral Weeks
Nov. 22nd: Tristan Nankervis: Slouching Towards Bethlehem
Nov. 26th: C.M. Crockford: The Lion in Winter