Intrusive Thoughts
Our annual deep dive into the array of works entering the public domain in the US
Happy days are here again—it’s Public Domain Day! Now, the very idea of public domain is complicated and region-specific. What we’re covering here is solely that in the US, wherein published works become public domain after 95 years and published songs (unless they were written for movies, in which case they follow movie rules) after a century. There are also rules about unpublished writing and art, and there’s this enormous mid-century muddle that I don’t understand fully because I am not merely not a lawyer but definitely not a copyright lawyer. But by and large, today marks the day when the entirety of the 1920s in literature and film comes into public domain.
We’ll start with Popeye, because goodness knows the Public Domain-to-Horror-Schlock pipeline is. He made his first appearance in the Segar comic strip Thimble Theatre in 1929. The strip had been running for ten years at that point—Olive Oyl has been public domain for a while, obviously—and rapidly became about the character intended to be one of many one-shot characters of the series. Now, only the comic character is the one in the public domain. Not the Fleischer cartoons and certainly not the Altman feature. Some of the characters from the comics are and some are not. Proceed with caution.
Tintin, presumably, is even more complicated, not least because the laws are different here than they are in the character’s native Belgium. But I don’t know about the assorted characters who work alongside of him. Snowy, okay, but Captain Haddock and Thompson and Thompson and so forth? No idea. And it’s the character, not even the fully published serial of Tintin in the Land of the Soviets, which was released in its entirety in 1930. And I don’t know the history of Belgian translation.
Over in Hollywood, there’s no better time to start introducing people to the Marx Brothers. The Cocoanuts, their first film, is now public domain. Hallelujah, the first major studio release with an all-black cast, and Showboat, though not the later one with Paul Robeson. We’re getting the last handful of silent films and the start of everyone’s first talkies. Blackmail from Alfred Hitchcock. The Wild Party from Clara Bow. The Black Watch from John Ford. Dynamite from Cecil B. DeMille. The first sound films featuring Charlie Chan and Sherlock Holmes and Fu Manchu. (Not, obviously, all in the same movie.) This was the year when Hollywood acknowledged that the change was here to stay.
Disney, long the company pushing the extension of copyright, loses a bit more this year, too. White-gloved Mickey and the first words he said. Horace Horsecollar, who deserves a bit more attention now that he is able to be explored by other people. The first five Silly Symphonies, including “The Skeleton Dance,” will now be available. Most of the cast has a while to go yet, but it’s still something that people were never expecting to happen. The Disney battles haven’t started yet, I suspect, but I think we may start to see those this year, too.
1929 was a busy year in literature, too. Fewer people are celebrating this one, but Ellery Queen enters the public domain today. Albert Campion, a once-popular character created by Margery Allingham and a possible parody of Lord Peter Wimsey. The original serialized version of The Maltese Falcon, by Dashiell Hammett, and the first English translation of All Quiet on the Western Front were released in 1929. The zombie, the classic Caribbean version, entered literature with The Magic Island, by William Seabrook. The first American “wordless novel,” a sort of predecessor to the modern graphic novel, was 1929’s Gods’ Man, by Lynd Ward. The Sound and the Fury, if you like Faulkner, and A Farewell to Arms, if you like Hemingway. Cup of Gold, the first novel by Steinbeck.
Meanwhile some stone-cold classic songs were written in 1929. “Singin’ in the Rain.” “Ain’t Misbehavin’.” The original composition of An American in Paris and Ravel’s Boléro, which I’ve just learned included scoring for an instrument that has never existed. (A sopranino saxophone in F.) Now, as a reminder, it’s only the songs themselves—you can tiptoe through the tulips all you want now, but not the Tiny Tim version. In recordings, however, we’re starting to see some of them break the century that their copyrights are held for. With apologies to my high school California history teacher, you can now listen to the original Jolson recording of “California, Here I Come.” At least you can make it better with the original recording of Rhapsody in Blue?
With visual art, it gets ridiculously complicated, because “published” is a tricky term in art. It’s not a pipe, but it may or may not be under copyright, is what I’m saying. But definitely works by Dalí and Hopper, Escher and Kandinsky. (It’s a big year for Dalí, as “Un Chien Andalou” enters the public domain in the US as well.) I’m not an art historian; we do have one of those around here, though, and you’d have to ask her for more about this. Even though I know the ‘20s are not her era.
We are just scraping the surface here. 1929 was a rich year, a year of enormous change in the US. We will be diving into the art of the Great Depression soon, the Roaring Twenties now behind us except in music because why should things be simple. Pandora’s Box was released in Germany. The Three Masks, France’s first sound film. But then there was a movie called The White Hell of Pitz Palu, starring an actress who would later go on to direct propaganda films of great artistic ability and less-than-great subject matter. On With the Show was not merely a talking film but in color. Comedy was talking and movies were singing. It’s an extraordinary world and one to explore, now freely.
About the writer
Gillian Nelson
Gillian Nelson is a forty-something bipolar woman living in the Pacific Northwest after growing up in Los Angeles County. She and her boyfriend have one son and one daughter, and she gave a child up for adoption. She fills her days by chasing around her kids, watching a lot of movies, and reading. She particularly enjoys pre-Code films, blaxploitation, and live-action Disney movies of the '60s and '70s. She has a Patreon account.
Gillian Nelson’s ProfileTags for this article
More articles by Gillian Nelson
Attention Must Be Paid
Arnold Stang, who appeared in a movie with "Arnold Strong" once.
Intrusive Thoughts
There was a time when musicals were about having the biggest gimmick possible.
Camera Obscura
One woman does what she can to help foster kids until she kind of becomes Cary Grant.
The Rockford Files Files
In which Jim is not exactly a bad mother, but his client is.
Department of
Conversation
I wonder if anyone not connected to Blumhouse wannabees is going to try to do something interesting with Popeye. Though it’s not like anyone really seems to care about him.
I looked around for a good poem to read last night to mark its liberation, but 1929 seems to have been a down year for famous poems. I settled for Singing in the Rain, and at least two guests were unaware that it was created for the beloved movie.
These are exciting times for the public domain, they are! I had no idea Ravel’s “Bolero” was a 1920s composition.
I’m also curious how Disney is going to respond to white glove Mickey going Public, because unlike Steamboat Willie we’re a lot closer to Mickey’s current look, especially since those newer shorts went back to dots for eyes. I expect a lot of lawyers are going to be getting a good workout.
Gee, Disney lawyers doing work. Wonder what that will look like.
And yeah, I didn’t know about the Ravel, either!
Everyone’s always surprised by how recent “Bolero” is, including me some years ago.
Also including Nintendo composer Koji Kondo, who says he planned to put an arrangement of it on the title screen for the first The Legend of Zelda game on NES. Reportedly, he found out late in production that the song wasn’t on the public domain, so he scrapped that version and took the main map theme and reworked into a slower, lower-key for the title screen. Curious if he’s still got the first arrangement somewhere now.
I’m a little surprised no one’s tried to reboot Ellery Queen. The name’s known from the magazine at least.
My kids have a cousin named Ellary Quinn [last name], and I’m sure she’s happier no one has. Her grandmother and I expressed bewilderment that she apparently isn’t named after the character.
Yeah, that’s an odd coincidence!