Close Search Close

 

  • Comics
  • Theatre
  • Site News

“You had me going for the first part. The second half, it kinda threw me.”

"That seems really dark."

When Glenn Howerton dies, “The Implication” will be on his gravestone. It’s his most famous line delivery in a career filled with great line deliveries and facial expressions – the way he lifts his eyelids a mere millimetre on exactly the right word, switching from friendly to dead-in-the-eyes absolutely effortlessly. Howerton is an incredibly physical actor – complete control over his body and voice, tuning it to whatever the scene needs. This is especially funny when he’s playing a pretentious guy like Dennis.

It’s Mac who pushes this scene from ‘great comedy scene’ to ‘iconic’, though. It would be easier for Charlie Day and Rob McElhenney (writers for this episode) to have Mac immediately push back on Dennis’s creepy idea; indeed, there are many scenes throughout the show that are based on this exact idea, usually involving Dee (a great one is when they’re both meeting with a psychiatrist in “Psycho Pete Returns”, and she provokes him into yelling “YOU FORGOT ABOUT THE SMELL, YOU BITCH!”). But they choose to have Mac do the single funniest thing you could do in this scene: take Dennis in good faith.

Over and over, Mac tries giving Dennis an out so that he doesn’t have to sound like a monster – surely this cannot be as bad as it sounds! But it’s just giving Dennis enough rope to hang himself. Dennis has chance after chance to take back what he’s saying and even recognises that, but he simply cannot resist revealing his monstrosity. Storytelling is based around someone making decisions, and comedy doesn’t necessarily have to be storytelling, but Always Sunny definitely runs on storytelling logic; comedy is based around setting up one expectation and then going another, and the simplicity of Always Sunny comes from these people almost always making the most wrong decision.

I think it’s what makes the show feel so simple and yet so effective; in the moment, a character’s decision is obvious even as it’s obviously wrong (although absurd and extreme enough in expression to be funny) – a character will just say a sexist thing as soon as a woman does anything, or a racist thing as soon as the topic of someone’s race comes up.  In a broader sense, each decision ends up escalating the character’s story in a logical way, so that absurd moments are contextualised by larger absurd stories.

This particular scene is one of those moments where the comedy gets a little more nuanced – I think in this case, the ‘wrong’ thing is for Mac to take Dennis at his word. I think most people would either tell Dennis what he’s saying is messed up, or simply try to ignore it, and very few people would assume Dennis had misspoken and work with him to help him express himself better (Mac’s cheerful expression on “I think that I am,” makes me laugh every single time). The scene gets funnier and funnier because both Mac and Dennis are really trying to make Dennis not sound like a rapist, and both keep failing miserably.