Close Search Close

 

  • Comics
  • Theatre
  • Site News

A Conspiracy Theory about VisionQuest

Do your research! They don't want you to know this! Wake up, sheeple!

You may be wondering why I watched VisionQuest, given my disdain for the MCU project. One of my complaints was that the movies were so devoid of meaning that the conversation around them, no matter how beautiful, had quickly devolved into the same conversation over and over. With that in mind, I’ll simply explain that my two thoughts going in were “This will be the same pageantry of bullshit the MCU has been dealing in for nearly two decades and the only difference is that they’ve put their meaningless platitudes in the mouth of James Spader and put him in a stupid hat,” versus “But he’s got a new hat!”. In this respect, my expectations were so low that I came out vaguely positive; the acting across the board is on Spader’s level, even if he’s the most fun to watch.

What’s more interesting is that I now have a conspiracy theory: Joss Whedon is doing script doctor work for the MCU. This conspiracy theory is like all conspiracy theories; for one, I have absolutely no evidence beyond vibes. For two, there’s nothing to be actually done with this information (I’m certainly not thinking anyone should boycott the MCU, for that reason anyway). Most important of all, though, it’s an extension of a thought someone else had – out of curiosity once, I looked up what Joss Whedon has actually done since his dramatic ‘cancellation’ a few years ago. Publicly, the only thing he’s done is support his new wife’s art exhibitions, but I saw speculation that he’s been doing anonymous script doctor work to pay the bills. 

It’s an interesting question in that people agree he’s a workaholic, and the question is whether he’s completely burned out after a lifetime of work, or whether his true nature is to work and he’s simply found a different expression of that. I figured it was more interesting as a philosophical question than as actual speculation; you’ve got Buffy and Avengers money and you’ve completely burned up your professional reputation, and you’ve been working your entire adult life (at one point, Whedon was working on four different shows, and he made two entirely different works while taking a break from working). Under those circumstances, would you still work? I probably would.

In the third episode of VisionQuest, there is a scene where Vision manages to prevent his own death by cauterizing his wound with battery acid from a car, and when he feels better, he remarks “I’ve achieved a state of not-quite-dying yet.” Now I know pragmatically that you can’t ‘diagnose’ someone off one line, and that nailing down what is written by who – especially in a television show with a large writer’s room – is about as scientifically sound as all those other amateurs reading the body language of celebrities in the news. And yet, I can’t help thinking that this sounds not Whedonesque, but just… Whedon. People talk about Whedon’s influence on Hollywood writing, but that sounds like the genuine article.

With Whedon, whenever he writes an actual cliche, he always finds a needlessly convoluted way of delivering it, as if he gets bored with the cliche before even writing it, which is partly why his style had such shock value at the time. To put it another way, Whedon is always chasing novelty; the funny thing about his imitators is that they often chain together cliches. A useful line to articulate this from Ultron in the same series, describing, in his view, the true story of the Ship of Theseus: “Each passing year, those same sons and daughters, soon wives and husbands, then mothers and fathers, restored that ship in celebration of that day.”

This is a sentence of segments tied together to make a larger rhetorical point, which itself is part of a series of sentences tied together to make an ostensibly original point. Whedon is brutally efficient when he’s trying to make a point and is only inefficient when he thinks it would be funny. He’s not generally interested in writing that kind of elaborate repetition – he’d probably get bored halfway through writing Ultron’s sentence back there. This is not to say that it’s worse, only that it would be a different and less Whedonesque choice.

One of the really interesting things about my little conspiracy theory here is that it adds an extra dimension to the philosophical question of Whedon’s script doctor work. Suppose you’ve got a friend and coworker who has tanked his career and is looking for work – perhaps because he needs the money, definitely because he has a drive to work. Not only that, he’s responsible for the success of your empire in the first place. All this to say that I could see Kevin Feige (or other producers for which Feige is standing in in this example) offering Whedon some script doctor work to help him out. After all, he did write and direct The Avengers.

And I admit to finding it kind of funny and with a small sense of justice here, in a very end-of-The-Shield kind of way. You’ve got this guy with the tremendous ego who aimed for (and achieved) more complete creative control and personal recognition than most people get, and because of his hubris, the only work he can get is anonymous grunt work to someone else’s vision. I don’t know if it’s what he deserves for the abuse and harassment he dealt out, particularly to women, but I’ll argue it’s poetry.