You may be wondering why I watched VisionQuest, given my disdain for the MCU project. One of my complaints was that the movies were so devoid of meaning that the conversation around them, no matter how beautiful, had quickly devolved into the same conversation over and over. With that in mind, I’ll simply explain that my two thoughts going in were “This will be the same pageantry of bullshit the MCU has been dealing in for nearly two decades and the only difference is that they’ve put their meaningless platitudes in the mouth of James Spader and put him in a stupid hat,” versus “But he’s got a new hat!”. In this respect, my expectations were so low that I came out vaguely positive; the acting across the board is on Spader’s level, even if he’s the most fun to watch.
What’s more interesting is that I now have a conspiracy theory: Joss Whedon is doing script doctor work for the MCU. This conspiracy theory is like all conspiracy theories; for one, I have absolutely no evidence beyond vibes. For two, there’s nothing to be actually done with this information (I’m certainly not thinking anyone should boycott the MCU, for that reason anyway). Most important of all, though, it’s an extension of a thought someone else had – out of curiosity once, I looked up what Joss Whedon has actually done since his dramatic ‘cancellation’ a few years ago. Publicly, the only thing he’s done is support his new wife’s art exhibitions, but I saw speculation that he’s been doing anonymous script doctor work to pay the bills.
It’s an interesting question in that people agree he’s a workaholic, and the question is whether he’s completely burned out after a lifetime of work, or whether his true nature is to work and he’s simply found a different expression of that. I figured it was more interesting as a philosophical question than as actual speculation; you’ve got Buffy and Avengers money and you’ve completely burned up your professional reputation, and you’ve been working your entire adult life (at one point, Whedon was working on four different shows, and he made two entirely different works while taking a break from working). Under those circumstances, would you still work? I probably would.
In the third episode of VisionQuest, there is a scene where Vision manages to prevent his own death by cauterizing his wound with battery acid from a car, and when he feels better, he remarks “I’ve achieved a state of not-quite-dying yet.” Now I know pragmatically that you can’t ‘diagnose’ someone off one line, and that nailing down what is written by who – especially in a television show with a large writer’s room – is about as scientifically sound as all those other amateurs reading the body language of celebrities in the news. And yet, I can’t help thinking that this sounds not Whedonesque, but just… Whedon. People talk about Whedon’s influence on Hollywood writing, but that sounds like the genuine article.
With Whedon, whenever he writes an actual cliche, he always finds a needlessly convoluted way of delivering it, as if he gets bored with the cliche before even writing it, which is partly why his style had such shock value at the time. To put it another way, Whedon is always chasing novelty; the funny thing about his imitators is that they often chain together cliches. A useful line to articulate this from Ultron in the same series, describing, in his view, the true story of the Ship of Theseus: “Each passing year, those same sons and daughters, soon wives and husbands, then mothers and fathers, restored that ship in celebration of that day.”
This is a sentence of segments tied together to make a larger rhetorical point, which itself is part of a series of sentences tied together to make an ostensibly original point. Whedon is brutally efficient when he’s trying to make a point and is only inefficient when he thinks it would be funny. He’s not generally interested in writing that kind of elaborate repetition – he’d probably get bored halfway through writing Ultron’s sentence back there. This is not to say that it’s worse, only that it would be a different and less Whedonesque choice.
One of the really interesting things about my little conspiracy theory here is that it adds an extra dimension to the philosophical question of Whedon’s script doctor work. Suppose you’ve got a friend and coworker who has tanked his career and is looking for work – perhaps because he needs the money, definitely because he has a drive to work. Not only that, he’s responsible for the success of your empire in the first place. All this to say that I could see Kevin Feige (or other producers for which Feige is standing in in this example) offering Whedon some script doctor work to help him out. After all, he did write and direct The Avengers.
And I admit to finding it kind of funny and with a small sense of justice here, in a very end-of-The-Shield kind of way. You’ve got this guy with the tremendous ego who aimed for (and achieved) more complete creative control and personal recognition than most people get, and because of his hubris, the only work he can get is anonymous grunt work to someone else’s vision. I don’t know if it’s what he deserves for the abuse and harassment he dealt out, particularly to women, but I’ll argue it’s poetry.
About the writer
Tristan J. Nankervis
Tristan J Nankervis (aka Drunk Napoleon) has been a writer, pop culture critic, dishwasher, standup comedian, waiter, potato cake factory worker, gamer, TV worker, and various other things. You can find him in Hobart, Tasmania.
Tristan J. Nankervis’s ProfileTags for this article
More articles by Tristan J. Nankervis
What you might call "edgy ambient".
Year of the Month
This is the angriest a book has made me since that fucking Ayn Rand book.
Department of
Conversation
What did we watch?
Live Music
Went to HOBOFOPO, the Hobart folk-punk festival this weekend. It was an educational experience; for example, folk-punk varies from one person with an acoustic guitar to a folk band where you can’t properly hear all the instruments to a traditional mostly-instrumental folk band where you can hear all the instruments and even to a dreamy pop-like rock band that included an accordion, a clarinet, and a fiddle. Oh yeah, and there was a rapper, but they also rapped over a ukelele they were playing so they definitely counted. It was interesting because it took place in about six different venues across Hobart’s CBD; this was the tenth anniversary, so there were a) lots of acts who had been to it from the start and b) lots of explanation and nostalgia that made it easy to keep up, and the original impetus was thinking “quite a few people want to play in Hobart, but the audience would get spread out, so why don’t we just all play on the same weekend in the same venues?”.
Most of the acts have albums out – of course the one I liked best of all were actually playing their first gig ever and thus do not, but even they were already part of the local music scene and so do have music out under other projects – so that’s going to take up my WDWLT threads for the next six months. The big unifying element to their music was generally direct lyrics that were extremely specific to the individual playing them, making covers either redundant or impossible, although even then there were a few that were hitting more universal themes in a kind of Tom Lehrer way.
Favourite band was Shrews, three middle aged women (I think?) who played what was structurally bubblegum pop from the Sixties (i.e. exactly my shit) with a more abrasive (but still hook-heavy) guitar, and with those Lehrer-esque lyrics tuned occasionally to feminism but sometimes to other shit – their opening song was about being stuck driving on the Midlands Highway, which I can confirm is extremely annoying.
I did also appreciate and respect how welcoming and encouraging the audiences were of different acts. One act was led by a trans woman that my partner told me had been at the festival since its inception, starting out as an amateur and working her way up to a full and very enthusiastic band. She told a story onstage about how the festival had been part of a journey out of depression and nihilism.
Happy Endings, Season Two, Episode Nineteen, “Party of Six”
“You can’t just go around Daylight-Savingses people!”
“Hoo-ah! Uh-oh, I’m stuck in a Pacino! Hoo-ah!”
“Hey, if Degrassi’s on the field, play ball, am I right? Sorry, proud of the wordplay, not the message.”
“That is the most hilarious near-death experience I’ve ever seen, and I’ve seen Anthony Anderson play tennis!”
“Wait. Darth Vader was a Nazi?”
“Max. You’re leaning on the light switch.”
“The curse of Max’s love handles has struck again.”
“All ideas are welcome as long as they’re not stupid.”
“Yeah, no reason to make that up.”
“As they say in Spanish, Jane and I got caught having sex in a bathroom.”
“Hey, you guys mind if I tag in?”
“If we didn’t want to get caught, we’d just have sex at home!”
“Yeah, ya dumb idiot!”
“And she’s right behind me, isn’t she?”
“No?”
“Oh right, that’s coz she’s over there.”
“Well, can he rent a u-haul without his parent’s signature, because I can.”
“His parents are dead.”
“Who buys half-eaten steak?”
This episode has a bit of a bottle episode element to it – obviously, it keeps moving around and also has flashbacks, but it is basically about these characters being stuck in conversation with each other. Like all bottle episodes, it really highlights the strength of this cast – the chemistry, weird oneliners, and quick timing. I suppose the flashbacks and opening also speak to this show absolutely needing to move around.
“Why don’t they put pizzas on all the menus?”
“Jane! There’s no food in your purse! I’m wasting away over here, and all you have is a bunch of newspaper clippings from when you used to figure skate!”
“You were born 31 years ago.”
“Plus, you have freakish upper body strength and probably could have unbolted that table and hit me with it.”
“Yeah, I could have.”
“You could have, yeah.”
“Yeah, we realised that when you cast yourself as the Drew Barrymoore figure in Never Been Kissed.”
“Nathan wasn’t a poet, he was a bard!”
“Talk about restaurants that maybe don’t exist. Where does Gollum eat?”
“Now she’s doing Goonies?”
“Dave. How quickly can you grow a moustache?”
“Quicker than most.”
“Doesn’t matter.”
“So your first instinct is to hide under the table. What’s the endgame here?”
“Nobody should own a restaurant but people like me, a restaurant owner.”
“I’m Dave.”
Hell yeah live music! Kudos to the organisers for an impeccably named event.
If there’s one thing my country has cornered the market on, it’s funny names for things.
Woooooooooooooo live music! I assume the festival’s name meant bands were required to perform folk-punk covers of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2up7su7CeMU
Devil in a Blue Dress – I really wanted to do some proper noir-viewing this month but it’s been an incredibly busy one so far. Really happy to have finally found the time to revisit this one though, it has stuck in my head pretty hard and I think I enjoyed it even more a second time around. Some neo-noir really pushes the bleakness / unpleasantness beyond a threshold where I still have fun with it but this one very distinctly feels like a love-letter to the classics, albeit with the Black protagonist giving it a lot of extra interesting edges and threats to add to the ones that white PIs face in the older films. Still a thrill when Don Cheadle enters the action like a hilariously unpredictable wrecking ball. I will offer the mandatory “damn it’s a shame they never made any more of these”.
Live Music – a weekend indie rock / pop fest in Cambridge. Bit of a disaster-riddled weekend, both personally and for the event (members of three bands were sharing a van down from the north-east and it broke down, so they had to scramble for late replacement acts) but there was still some fun to be had. I particularly enjoyed indie-folk act Two White Cranes doing a set of Martha covers on the Friday night (Martha being one of my very favourite bands) and the Saturday closing act, R. Aggs, who kept apologising for being unwell but still delivered a joyful set of electronic pop with looped violin and guitar parts. Also I ate some incredible tacos, A+, would go again.
Fuck yeah Mouse and Tom Sizemore too.
I still marvel at the fact that no one has bought the rights to the Easy Rawlins books for a streaming series. I am not terribly surprised, but it seems like such an…err…easy choice to make.
Oh same, Walter Mosley has also been working with FX long enough that you’d think he’d have some pull and get it going.
Wooooooooo live music! Wooooooo live tacos!
And yeah, Devil is great.
Lady Jane – Chose this as it came up on a list of movies with Sir Patrick Stewart (RIP), and as much as i love him as Capt. Picard, it’s always great to see him in other roles. And while his part is relatively small – the father of the title character – it’s very meaty. The film is about Lady Jane Grey, who was chosen by the dying boy king Edward VI to be his heir to prevent the Catholic Princess Mary from taking over (even though dear old dad Henry VIII approved just that). Poor Jane, who had no say in the matter, was technically queen for nine days before it was clear that Mary had the support of the people (and also a bigger army). The history is fascinating, and at least some of what actually happened is depicted here, though the sweet romance between Jane and the son of the king’s regent is a total fabrication. Trevor Nunn, a legendary theater director, isn’t really great at movies, but the production values and the acting cover for a lot of sins (like the movie’s length and a script that insists on giving Jane and her lover fairly progressive ideals). Helena Bonham Carter bursts onto the scene here, setting the right tone as a woman of 16 who is at once self serious, romantic, cynical, and hopeful. Cary Elwes is very good as her husband, finding the right level of chemistry. Camera work by Douglas Slocombe. (Wacky fact: there is a romantasy version of this out there. Oh for just one historical work that strives to get things right.)
Elementary, “Fit to Be Tied”/”Whatever Remains, However Impossible” – The serial killer plot collapses entirely when both the latest victim is not actually his handiwork AND when he’s found murdered at the end of the fomer episode. Overall, the idea never really works. But the latter episode focuses on how the FBI think Joan committed the murder, and how the truth is pretty awful. And the only way out is for Holmes himself to confess to a murder he didn’t commit, and then call in favors from MI6 that allow him to return to London and not be extradited. And strangely, the season finale works very well because it focuses on Joan and Sherlock and because the truth – it was Gregson’s daughter (also a cop) who did it and Gregson is covering up for her – is really not what we expect. Plus…this was designed to be a series finale, only the show’s ratings (overseas, IIRC) rallied and the sixth season went from 13 episodes to 21 and was un-cancelled. And this would have been a very good series finale. But 13 more episodes await.
Barney Miller, “Goodbye, Mr. Fish,” part two – Fish finally shows up for work, but cannot face that it’s his last day. And as with the first part, things are played quite seriously as Fish has to accept the end. (There really is a retirement age for police in NYC. It was 63 at the time, 65 now.) The farewells to Fish are quite heartfelt, too.
MASH, “Hepatitis” – Father Mulcahy comes down sick, and Hawkeye (suffering from a bad back) is the one to give everyone blood tests and gamma globulin shots. Leading to a surprising scene where not only does Frank let Hawkeye treat him but also then demands Hawkeye examine his (psychosomatic) ailments. And also leading to Hawk giving Margaret a shot in her bum and him not treating the moment with respect. Meanwhile BJ has to do surgery using a medical journal as his only guide. A solid mix of comedy and light drama.
Maverick, “Point Blank”/”According to Hoyle” – Going to be hard to write about these since the plots so far are all very similar: Bret gets into trouble, Bret deals with other con artists who are less good natured and honest, Bret uses his wits more than his fists. The show is fun if a bit slow paced, and who doesn’t love seeing more James Garner? But there might not be much to say.
Oh man, would definitely rank “Hepatitis” as a top five episode of the show. With Hawkeye being a putupon smart ass and BJ having to brute force learning a medical technique, it’s pretty much the platonic ideal of a M*A*S*H episode.
And everyone gets to do something interesting.
Tales From The Crypt, two very satisfying episodes, “Beauty Rest” and “What’s Cookin’?” (though yeesh are the titles generic.) The first has Mimi Rogers as an increasingly murderous actress who wanders into the wrong beauty pageant, hosted by Buck Henry(!) and the second features Christopher Reeves and Bess Armstrong as restauranteurs who unwittingly cook some long pig thanks to Judd Nelson’s drifter. The first has that uneasy mix of misogyny and confrontation of sexism I’ve found in a lot of good exploitation and trash, the second is classic, gleeful horror-comedy that lets Reeves play some different notes than he had as Superman.
The Lowdown S2E4 – Very funny and off-kilter episode that introduces Martha Plimpton as Boontill’s sheriff, who I didn’t recognize at first with her sunglasses and butch haircut. I would have the exact same reaction as Lee to drinking raw milk except I’d shit myself even faster.
Hacks S5E5 – The season centers around Deborah’s legacy as well as who Ava will be with or without her; this means a very fun Amazing Race episode that’s more about Deborah’s relationship with DJ. Much as DJ is a weird nepo baby, she’s built her own identity outside her mom and is pretty fearless, even going for a clown routine she cannot possibly master. Jefferson Mays is back too as the antique dealer Ava blackmailed in S1.
Watching Lee drink lots of tequila: Ha ha, hell yeah brother
Watching Lee drink one raw milk: You absolute moron. What are you doing to your body
Lone Star — a remarkable movie that I am juuuuuuuuuuuuust a bit to the side on. The performances are wonderful and the direction is unfussy but purposeful, the pan-to-the-past technique is great and it’s the only really showy thing here. Where Sayles really excels is in writing and editing, he juggles a lot of stuff here (three different parent/child plots, with an extra two when you consider the children of the children) and a ton of literal history, but his characters never feel like mouthpieces (Ron Canada has a great little aside about how he’s helped keep or at best ignored others keeping other black businesses down over the years, it helps keep his business going). They fuck up and re-enact the past, which they don’t even know or have forgotten, and when they do uncover it they find things they wish they hadn’t. The two qualms I have come with some slightly wonky mechanics of the ending’s big reveal (in terms of who was likely to know what, Sayles seems to pass over implications he can’t reconcile) and with the larger issue of the present as a consideration of the past instead of its own generation of future past — most of the action in the film takes place in the 50s and 60s, not the contemporary 90s. But that audacious ending helps a lot here, two people making a choice that may one day be uncovered and change everything to the people of the future. We’ve all got to live with something, if we’re living.
Odd Man Out — another classic, another movie I didn’t fully vibe with, although this one had more issues. Part of this is my fault, I confused it with The Informer, another movie about an IRA guy in the soup and as the title suggests is about fucked loyalties, it took a bit for the penny to drop that OMO is up to something different. Very different, as the title reflects lead James Mason’s presence in his own film — Mason leads a Legally Not IRA heist on a mill, Carol Reed films this as straightforward crime and it whips ass, but of course it goes south and Mason kills a guy while getting badly shot himself. And at this point he becomes a largely passive and silent character, staggering around and hallucinating and essentially an object that the people of Legally Not Belfast deal with, most recognize him and want nothing to do with him but also don’t want to actively turn him over to the cops. All of this looks astounding, Robert Krasker shot this before working with Reed again on The Third Man and this is not so much a dry run for that film as a more phantasmagorical version of its dark alleys and urban jungle; this is in service of the film moving into a more metaphorical mode as Mason approaches death — I believe there are some stations of the cross here — and the incredible images can’t cover how the characters also become increasingly metaphorical, constructs instead of people. The status of Mason’s soul is not as interesting to me because I’ve spent time with him as a vessel more than a person (the various bits involving his gang are more standard crime and much more interesting to me), but fortunately Kathleen Ryan as Mason’s dame is around to ground things, and she pulls together the astonishing final scene where she and Mason and Krasker and Reed all come together in an unearthly depiction of an earthly act. Writing at the time, James Agee said the movie was frequently half-baked but also constantly striving for greatness, he’s right and that last bit of striving makes up for a lot.
Live music — was by a small club I’m usually not near and took a flier after checking out the bill and being intrigued. Local band Good Karma opened with punk/emo with a big late 90s/early aughts influence (some nu-metal-ish breakdowns!), they were a lot of fun and set up Toronto’s The OBGMs, a four-piece punk band that also had a few emo-ish leanings in terms of lyrical content but more importantly had absolutely phenomenal energy, the kind of band that plays a room of 100 people like they’re in a stadium, and vocalist Densil McFarlane has charisma for days, leading mosh pits and joking with his band and getting everyone in a Boston crowd hopping. Said crowd was still Boston and had a fair amount of old guys (ahem) and we were losing our shit, younger people with less inhibitions would probably be on the moon right now. As it is I think a lot of people will be lying about attending this show in the future, the band is not to be missed if they come through your town (and it sounded like they have a new album in the works so hopefully that will be sooner rather than later). Hell yeah.
What did we play?
Gears of War, Act One, Chapter Five, “Knock Knock”
Gameplay-wise, this has a simple but fun section where you have to push through to a nest that’s up some stairs – not a lot, just enough for them to have high ground over you – and, when you take that section, end up having to defend it. It’s very simple but I enjoy that process a lot, and the level design is well-suited to it (though the game also orders you to attack it in a suicidal way for some reason).
Story-wise, the character Carmine gets killed by a sniper when he puts his head up complaining about his weapon jamming. I suspect this comes from someone on the creative team hearing about the phrase ‘redshirt’ – notice Carmine’s name – but not fully grasping how it’s supposed to fit into a story. It wasn’t just happening for no reason, it was to establish stakes and the method of how the enemy o’ the week kills people. I guess this is where the sniper rifle is introduced, but come on. If I care about Carmine dying, it’s because his AI is amusingly aggressive despite his bland demeanour.
This also introduces an obstacle in that the radios stop working. More on that next week.
Max Payne, Part One, “The American Dream”, “Prologue”
I’m having so much fun writing about Gears that I’ve decided to go through Max Payne the exact same way. MP isn’t really any more meaningful than Gears, but right from the beginning, it’s so much more vivid and imaginative, and, to be frank, better designed. The first cutscene before anything happens is a flashforward to the end of the game, where Max reflects on how it feels like the end of a long journey, and that gets to the grounding element of the whole thing: Max’s feelings about everything happening around him.
It jumps back to ‘three years ago’, where we and Max stumble on the murder of his wife and child. Serious cutscenes are presented in a faux comic book style; they’re actually still photographs of the game crew (with Max himself played by creator Sam Lake, who wildly overacts whereas voice actor James Mcaffrey underacts) arranged to slowly reveal as the voice acting catches up, which looks really cool as well as goofy, and it’s fun to get into the spirit of it. Already, it compensates for silliness with details; my favourite is Max remarking that he’s quitting smoking before he goes home.
You kind of get the nature of the thing in how nothing before the basic situation of the story matters; Max has a wife and child in the suburbs, with no delving into Max’s history or his wife’s history or the history of the world or anything like that. There will be diving into the world itself, but from here on out, anything about Max from before his family got murdered will not matter. This obviously doesn’t completely kill this as a mystery or a noir (I don’t think we get anything about Sam Spade’s history and I know it doesn’t factor into the Operative), but I do think it points to the priorities and specific intellectual curiosities of the series.
There are three interesting details in the prologue. The first two are basic foreshadowing that adds a sense of dread, and is part of the game being more of an emotional experience than a drama or intellectual one. The first is a big symbol spray-painted on Max’s wall: a symbol of a V with a syringe through it, which will be associated with the drug that the murderers of Max’s family were on and which drives the plot. The other is a phone call Max gets in which he talks to a mysterious woman who confirms his identity and hangs up; naturally, this is the villain of the game.
The third is the most interesting; when hearing Max’s wife get murdered, the player can actually move around through his bathroom and nudge the door to his bedroom open slightly, giving you a tantalising vision of what’s happening with an inability to stop it. What brings together all three images is, specifically, that they are images – with the third one being a complex setpiece. This speaks to what video games specifically can achieve, where you have limited control over a quasi-living environment. I specifically like how the third setpiece slams you into a limited amount of control; it’s a simple but very vivid emotional experience where you’re completely in Max’s head about having to rush around, too late to prevent a horrible event. It also speaks to game’s interest in emotional intensity specifically (layered in is the eerie sound of the baby’s mobile).
There’s also a few good video game moves here – exploring Max’s house rewards you with a shotgun instead of a simple pistol, which makes it much easier to take down the enemies – if you headshot, it takes down enemies instantly, and that’s easier to do with a shotgun. Max Payne uses structured setpieces for gunfights to make it easier to program enemy behaviour, which ironically rewards you for skill quite well (timing, aiming). It also does a neat little thing where Max is in a suit, separating this section from the rest of the game when he’s in a leather jacket and more casual outfit.
Small detail: all the cutscenes are scored to the exact same piece of music, which itself is a moody and atmospheric version of the main theme. I enjoy this for the same reason that I enjoy “Laura Palmer’s Theme” being all over Twin Peaks – I love when music in a work crosses over into a kind of wallpaper, especially when a work is shooting for a very specific atmosphere, and I particularly like it when that music has a very strong personality and hooks (or at least the atmospheric version of hooks).
Heh, I can’t dispute your detective work on that first line and I also think the second line is much better (and the repetition is necessary for the point). But I think there are some closer analogies than The Shield here — one is how Tim League of the Alamo Drafthouse hired Devin Faraci to write under the table and out of the public eye after Faraci was accused of sexual assault. A guy helping out his friend! Whedon has not been accused of the same thing of course, but the issue of “hey, why am I working with this creep now” remains. And the big comparison in screenwriting is blacklisted writers using fronts in the 50s, having friends slide them work because they lost their livelihoods due to the actual damn government as opposed to general disapproval. I don’t think that comparison does Whedon any favors either, although I wouldn’t be surprised if he saw it the other way.
Year of the Month updates:
We’ll be wrapping up 2026 with a look back at 2020! Here’s some lists of movies, albums, books, and TV to get you started.
Dec. 3rd: Cori Domschot: Underwater
Dec. 4th: Gillian Nelson: The Owl House
Dec. 6th: Tristan Nankervis: Mank
Dec. 11th: Gillian Nelson: Prop Culture
Dec. 18th: Joseph Finn: The Queen’s Gambit
Dec. 20th: Tristan Nankervis: Birds of Prey/Invisible Man
Dec. 25th: Gillian Nelson: COVID closings at the Disney parks
And there’s still time to write about anything from 1968 this month — here’s some lists of movies, albums, books, and TV to get you started.
TBD: Bridgett Taylor: Black Lizard
TBD: Cameron Ward: Horus, Prince of the Sun
TBD: Ruck Cohlchez: Astral Weeks
Nov. 19th: John Bruni: The Swimmer
Nov. 22nd: Tristan Nankervis: Slouching Towards Bethlehem
Nov. 26th: C.M. Crockford: The Lion in Winter
I’ll take Mank for December 6th and a double feature of The Invisible Man and Birds of Prey for the 20th please, Sam.