Close Search Close

 

  • Comics
  • Theatre
  • Site News

I hate NCIS

It radiates evil.

You know, the thing that gets me about NCIS is that I still think the pilot holds up. It’s quirky, it’s interesting, and the characters are plausible underdogs doing a difficult thing with a clever solution. Gibbs (Mark Harmon) comes off as a guy who loves his job so much he’ll express nothing but patience with people who don’t get it, and Tony DiNozzo (Michael Weatherly) is younger, more defensive and prickly, desperate for Gibbs’s approval, but ultimately hardworking. The show is inherently propaganda for the US military (George W Bush is a character, and one of the first scenes is a marine proud to meet him), but it’s not like that ever got in the way of entertainment.

I clearly remember turning on the show. I was sixteen, so it must have been some way through season four, when it occurred to me how often the characters did blatantly illegal things to uphold the law – the most common being that they hack into databases to get information, but once that thought wormed its way into my brain, I started to realise how often they lied about warrants, harassed suspects who hadn’t, from their perspective, actually done anything, and generally acted above the law.

From there it clicked for me how unlikeable the characters were. They had a weird habit of bullying people who had done literally nothing to them; McGee was their favourite punching bag, and I couldn’t understand why they were making his job more difficult (the appeal of hazing has always been lost on me). Tony keeps harassing women and gets weirdly petulant about it; Gibbs is a complete dickhead who comes off, at points, as sociopathically indifferent.

(Though I admit to having come around on his habit of destroying and replacing phones with a cavalier regularity, as well as writing in notepads)

The thing that really made me turn on the show was coming to recognise that, no matter their faults, the characters would never be wrong, never make a huge mistake, never be misled by their gut. It struck me as simultaneously blatant authoritarian propaganda – don’t question the system, don’t question the police – and poor, tedious writing.

[I]f he is a god or if he is, you know, an utterly fantastic creature, then the situation is of no challenge, and the resolution is never in doubt, and somehow, it’s, I dunno, it becomes a sort of bizarre religious ritual or something.

John McTiernan

The older I got, the more this show began to radiate evil to me. I know that sounds ridiculous – like I’m a fundamentalist Christian railing against the evils of pop culture, and in a way I guess I am. The smugness, the laziness, the lack of any real thought or interest in other people; I have to physically leave the room when I see this show is on now. Copaganda doesn’t necessarily turn me off; I can happily watch Law & Order and then still criticise it. This, on the other hand, is rank to me.

Even the little things about this show bother me; there’s a bizarre habit it indulges in where characters rigidly alternate between expositing about the plot and talking about whatever dumb shit is happening in their personal lives. Even aside from the facts that no human being talks like that and that it’s infuriating rather than cute (especially after the first five hundred times), it just draws attention to how superfluous the plot is.

One of the most infamous scenes from the show is two of the characters using the same keyboard to fight a hacking attempt (before Gibbs manfully solves the problem by unplugging the monitor), and this is just a particularly visual expression of how problems are both caused and solved by a sluice of bullshit. One can compare it to the nonsense on Law & Order or Criminal Minds; those shows are equally bullshit, but there’s a sense of the writers having worked out their bullshit so it makes internal.

These are the images that are coming at you – this is what the collective, anonymous body wants to see.

Werner Herzog

NCIS doesn’t even have that. I’ve heard rumours – mostly related to that keyboard scene – that the writers have contests to see who can generate the most absurd bullshit, and this is the kind of thing that doesn’t even need to be true because it successfully conveys the meaninglessness of it. Part of the reason NCIS radiates evil to me is because it’s often content for the sake of content; this combination of authoritarian politics and verbal diarrhea is a disturbing one.

It being the most popular TV show of all time is particularly disturbing. I don’t generally care or think about the obscurity of my taste; I must admit to being self-absorbed enough to believe that a show only needs to entertain me, and the rest of you can watch whatever you want. But knowing that this is what the people want to see – the authoritarian archetypes delivering gibberish to save us all – it’s hard not to worry about what that society would do to a person.