Close Search Close

 

  • Comics
  • Theatre
  • Site News

Disney Byways

So How Is Disney+?

The annual examination of the state of Disney+, possibly featuring a link or two.

It’s November again, and that means two things here at Media Magpies headquarters. One, it’s almost time to start planning out Year of the Month for next year. And two, it’s time to pay the Disney+ bill for the year again. And I will die mad that there is not more overlap involved. It’s not that I expect Disney+ to have every single obscure educational short—though there are some that I’m salty about—but I’ve got a running antagonism about the fact that for example I’m going to have to track down the Merlin Jones movies through other sources.

I do pay for Disney+ every year. I’m a day-one subscriber. Now, my argument is that it’s for work, and it is. There are things I am able to find for the column on Disney+. Easily a dozen a year. I didn’t have to pay money for Maleficent or Halloweentown, and aren’t we all happier because of that? I certainly am. On the other hand, I rented Never a Dull Moment this month, and for quite a lot of things I had to go to even greater lengths, because they aren’t even available to rent.

The promise of Disney+ was the end of the Vault. This was what we were all waiting for. No more Vault. Again, the bare minimum on this as far as I was concerned was the features. And, okay, we knew Song of the South was a no, and I’m not saying it shouldn’t be. But Make Mine Music remains off the platform probably because of its last segment despite the rest of it including some of the most beloved segments of the lesser package films. (As in, everything but Fantasia and Ichabod and Mr. Toad.) It’s still in the canon and still not on the platform.

As for live action, well. I dislike their new search function intensely, as it churns up all kinds of things that have nothing to do with your search rather than admit how scanty the results are—but if you’re looking for one specific thing, you should only get one result anyway. Leaving aside the Parent Trap sequels, Hayley Mills made seven movies for Disney. Four of them are on Disney+, and none of the Parent Trap sequels are. Five Tommy Kirk movies are on there, but he’s a minor character in two of them and several of his starring roles are missing.

I know I tend to focus on classic Disney stuff. The platform does not. Currently what they’re trying to do is make me bundle with Hulu, which I’m not doing because I can barely afford the plan I have now. They’re letting me watch season one of The X-Files, but only season one. They’re hyping that I could watch sports, but if I wanted to watch sports, I wouldn’t watch Disney+. I’m there to watch Disney things. (And, okay, The X-Files, but shhh.) I wouldn’t bundle with ESPN if I could afford it.

Me? I love Disney. If I didn’t, would I even have this column?

The problem, I think, is that Disney has in many ways lost their way. They’re trying too hard to be all things to everyone. Despite that, they are lacking in true experimentation. They’re playing it safe. They’re chasing what they think people want instead of going for genuine creativity. I think they need to accept that some people are just not interested in Disney. Me? I love Disney. If I didn’t, would I even have this column? Between Disney+ and Dreamlight Valley, Disney has gotten nearly three hundred of my household’s American dollars this week. I’m a sucker.

But I am not normal in that way. Especially for someone who does not consider herself a “Disney adult.” I don’t like that term and never have, though I’ll admit there are some people best described by it, people who make it their whole personality, which I do not. Still, I would argue I am by this point something of a minor Disney historian, and I’m a lifelong connoisseur of Disney IP, as I’ve said something I wish didn’t apply because I’m never sure I’ve spelled the word right. Still, I know more about the company than, I strongly suspect, most of their executives do.

I strongly believe the problem is that the executives are only interested in money. This seems obvious, I know. But say what you like about Walt—and oh, I could and have—he was interested in so much more. He was a man of ideas. Granted, there was Roy, and Roy was a fan of money, but there was always a Walt.

In the end, it feels as though the problem with Disney+, aside from the fact that prices keep going up, is that Disney feels ashamed to be Disney. It’s not that they want to be more; it’s that they don’t want to be what they are. I’m watching “Ben and Me” on YouTube with my son as I write this, on a channel that appears to have more Wonderful World of Color than Disney+ does. This is because it’s a special that also has, yes, “Peter and the Wolf.” From Make Mine Music. But this sort of thing is about the only way the kids see Walt; he’s hardly on the platform at all.

I’m not saying try to appeal exclusively to the Disney Adults. In part, because I think you have to have wider appeal than that. But also, I’m not sure how much most of them care about the studio’s history, either. Are there Disney Adults who can tell you about Humphrey the Bear? I suspect there are very few. The movies, I suppose, though the fondness is probably strongest for the princess films and weaker for things like Fun and Fancy Free—admittedly one I’m not a huge fan of myself. And I don’t know how much the average Disney Adult thinks of the live action at all.

Still, be unashamedly Disney. You should be able to find lots of Walt. Lots of the shorts. Lots of the silly live action movies and the True-Life Adventures. Even White Wilderness, which I maintain is like ninety percent a good movie. Except that one sequence. And, sure, the Disney Channel Original Movies and the Disney Channel TV shows, and I’m not saying I mind watching The X-Files on the channel. But come on. You’re Disney. Admit it. Even revel in it. And give me my Merlin Jones movies and Summer Magic, for pity’s sake.

Want to support more great writing like this? Get exclusive member benefits like access to our Discord, early access to Media Magpies content, and more by joining our Patreon!