Close Search Close

 

  • Comics
  • Theatre
  • Site News

The Movie Moments of 2024

The Nickel Boys welcome you to a look back at the movies this past year.

Does anybody remember what it was like to go into the future with confidence? To have faith that bad possibilities were out there but for every misstep there was another opportunity for something great just around the corner?

Iโ€™m talking about going to the movies, of course, what else could I possibly be alluding to. It was a strange, wonderful, frustrating, rewarding year for the movies, with schedules feeling residual effects of the strikes last year and indies elbowing for room alongside increasingly moribund franchise entries. The box office numbers may have never corresponded less with the most influential cinematic moments in the years to come.

A reminder! This is not a ranking of the best movies of the year (because the best one is in a measly number 4 spot) but the best movie moments, the point where our breath caught or an image or a line stuck in the brain even through anything else that might have been going on in the world to dislodge it. In fact, the rankings are pretty arbitrary. But please argue about them as if they werenโ€™t! The list skews toward the options available to an English-speaking Midwesterner, so thanks to John Bruni, Not David Lynch, and Cori Domschot for their contributions to help fill in blind spots. Feel free to fill in this articleโ€™s other missed movie moments of 2024 in the comments below.


Emergency Additions!

Unconscionably, two of the most memorable films of the year were left off this list (the excuse – they’re both listed on Letterboxd as coming out all the way back in 2022 due extensive festival runs and/or pending litigation with a major studio). These movies were the year’s best examples of working outside the system, so maybe it’s appropriate that they be featured outside the list.

Image: SRH

Hundreds of Beavers – The Trial

The way this glorious DIY slapstick comedy moves you may not be surprised that the pesky beavers our hunter pursues have built a large fortress in record time. But you may not suspect they have also set up a fully functioning judiciary system inside, complete with a beaver judge in a powdered wig and hapless beaver public defender. This is a mild spoiler, there’s even more inside than you’d expect.

Image: Altered Innocence

The People’s Joker – Origin Story

Vera Drew authored the only superhero film to make this year’s list at all, remixing DC property with constantly shifting mediums tied together with a heart-on-sleeve emotional skeleton. Deadpool may have been kinda snarky about all his superhero pals, but did he cut between live action, cell animation and puppetry with abandon while sharing emotional pain and catharsis? Game goes to Joker the Harlequin.

Image: A24

23) Civil War โ€“ Confrontation with Jesse Plemons

A24โ€™s foray into blockbuster season was a mixed bag of provocative ideas and deflating executions. Though speaking of executions, the standout scene clearly belonged to a Plemonsโ€™ rural militia leader when the film takes advantage of the actorโ€™s ability to keep you guessing about his intentions while hinting that all guesses should be bad.

Image: Netflix

22) Hit Man โ€“ Confession

It was the year of Glen Powell, we were told, thanks to his owning of January with the holdover 2023 hit Anyone But You and the summer blockbuster Twister. But giving him some credibility juice was a fun early summer release which he co-wrote and starred in. Too bad it was for Netflix which more or less dumped it into the stream with everything else.

Image: Lionsgate

21) Megalopolis โ€“ โ€œStop time for meโ€

Maybe it would be more appropriate to feature one of the lines clowned on by online folk, a number higher than the number that actually saw Francis Ford Coppolaโ€™s ungainly โ€œfable.โ€  Classics like โ€œGo back to the cluuuubโ€ or โ€œWhat do you think about this boner Iโ€™ve got?โ€ But weโ€™ll give some grace to this incoherent warning about a modern empire falling into disarray (thanks, Francis, hadnโ€™t noticed) and spotlight one of its few gems, a swooning romantic moment where the world freezes just for two lovers.

Image: A24

20) Sing Sing โ€“ The play

Perhaps the best cast assembled for a film this year played the cast of a (quite silly-looking) play put on by inmates in a maximum-security prison. Led by national treasure Colman Domingo, the cast includes a number of people playing versions of themselves from the real-life drama program that inspired the film. Clarance Maclin is the standout among this group, get that man the standard rich and famous contract.

Image: Warner Bros.

19) Furiosa: A Mad Max Saga โ€“ A different kind of chase

After nearly a decade since wandering The Wasteland, George Miller returned with this prequel. The movie had hard road to navigate to live up to its manic precursor, but Miller set the tone for a different โ€“ if also exciting โ€“ kind of action movie with a prolonged chase scene that demonstrated Fury Roadโ€™s mania could scale and still have what it takes to make it epic.

Image: Netflix

18) Daughters โ€“ The dance

Most of this documentary is about long-term prisoners preparing for the annual father-daughter dance. For many, the upcoming evening represents the only time theyโ€™ll be able to spend time with their daughters in many years. If this sounds like a wind-up for a big payoff, it is.

Image: Netflix

17) The Remarkable Life of Ibelin โ€“ Rewind

Little did the parents of Mats Steen realize what went on when he spent hours and hours on his computer in the years before finally succumbing to muscular dystrophy. When a password opens up his World of Warcraft account to them, the documentary rewinds to restart Steenโ€™s story, this time including his rich online life.

Image: Janus Films

16) The Beast – Lรฉa Seydoux Screams

Lรฉa Seydoux lets out a blood-curdling scream three times in The Beast. The first time, director Bertrand Bonello is letting you know that this is a movie that will force you to consider how real everything is. The second time, he wants to poke holes in the most intense moment of the film. And the final one of the one that sticks with you. That one is the emotional heart of the film. How would you react to watching someone losing their humanity? You scream with all you’ve got. The intensity of that moment elevates the film to another level. In another world, Seydoux is a scream queen with the best set of lungs you’ve heard in a horror film. Fortunately, we got The Beast instead. –NDL

Image: FX

15) Spermworld  – A screening of Mulholland Drive

Don’t let the title fool you, this is a real movie, and one of the yearโ€™s best. The heir to Errol Morrisโ€™ The Gates of Heaven, this documentary about the above-board yet underground world of online sperm donation is one of the funniest and most touching movies and itโ€™s buried on Hulu. Go find it.

Image: Anna Kooris/A24 via AP

14) Love Lies Bleeding โ€“ Bodybuilding competition

Before director Rose Glass takes her biggest swing with an ending to remember, Love Lies Bleeding rides that bleeding edge between the fantastic and visceral in a body-building competition that treats steroids as a cross between brown acid and Popeyeโ€™s spinach.

Image: Pixar

13) Inside Out 2 โ€“ Embrace

The yearโ€™s biggest hit arrived with a bitter taste as it marked a perhaps permanent turn for Pixar into a mere content creator, mining their own property for box office returns rather than making room for the kind of innovative storytelling that put them on the map. And yet, in this year with no shortage of cynical sequels (including from elsewhere in the House of Mouse), Inside Out 2 actually spoke to young audiences in way most โ€œfamilyโ€ movies wouldnโ€™t even try. The cold math may have been what got us to a revelation about acceptance, but a wordless embrace contains genuine feeling.

Image: Emily Mkrtichian

12) There Was, There Was Not โ€“ War comes to Artsakh

Mkrtichianโ€™s documentary follows the day-to-day efforts of four women as they inch closer to their aspirations in uncertain times. Suddenly, war breaks out, and all ambitions – of the film and the women – crumble. The before-and-after conveys the terrible price exacted on those who only months ago could more confidently pursue their better selves and simple freedom in their homeland, and what it takes to find a way forward when the future offers no certainty.

Image: Universal Pictures

11) The Wild Robot – Emerging from the wreckage

From the moment Roz (Lupita Nyong’o) crash lands on a small island you feel for her. This movie makes you feel everything. Loneliness, fear, and hope. The themes of friendship and family are strong in this movie. I am so grateful for this movie because it lets people know you can find your tribe, and they can be your family. –CD

Image: Sideshow/Janus Films

10) Evil Does Not Exist โ€“ Town hall meeting goes awry

Ryลซsuke Hamaguchi is not afraid to let a moment play out. And here, in his gentle ode to nature and small-town life turnedโ€ฆ something else, the most electrifying sustained moment is a public meeting between representatives of a luxury camping site and the townspeople their project would disrupt. Itโ€™s not a violent confrontation but Hamaguchi doesnโ€™t shy away from the tension in the room, letting it play out on its own terms, even as the conflict feels much larger than the crowded multi-purpose room.

Image: Warner Bros.

9) Juror #2 โ€“ Justin realizes the truth

Old master Clint Eastwood makes a potboiler weighing the vagaries of the justice system while getting sidelined by another system. Warner Brothers torpedoed this filmโ€™s chance at being a box office hit but at least some of the audience hungry for well-crafted drama found it nevertheless. Viewers were (and will continue to be on the streaming service Max) rewarded with solid cinematic storytelling, kicked off by cutting between a courtroomโ€™s account of a murder, a flashback to the night in question, and a member of the jury played by Nicholas Hoult who realizes only he knows the full truth โ€“ and that truth will not set him free.

Image: MGM

8) Challengers โ€“ The final point

Speaking of adult dramas, the spring season brought promise of a sexy tรชte-ร -tรชte โ€“ or more accurately a tรชte-ร -tรชte-ร -tรชte โ€“ with tennis pros competing on the court and in the bedroom. There was much back-and-forth about whether the result was really sexy enough, but director Luca Guadagnino supplemented the bedroom sweat with the sporty kind and, thanks to some tricky visual effects and a tennis balls-out approach to the action, pulled off the ultimate accomplishment for a sports movie โ€“ genuine tension as to what would happen in the end.

Image: A24

7) Janet Planet – Consciousness-raising session

At the emotional midway point of Janet Planet, Janet and her friend are tripping hard, pondering the big questions. Janet asks if her bad decisions were really โ€œbad.โ€ Her friend accuses her of copping out. Then we realize that Janetโ€™s 11-year old daughter, Lacy, has been listening in to this consciousness-raising session between the two women whom she trusts the most. Janet Planet shows us the tense negotiations that ensue when pre-teens live in, but are not completely part of, the adult world… –JB

Image: Metrograph Pitures

6) Good One – Late-night innuendo

…Yet, as Good One demonstrates, being on closer terms with the adult world doesnโ€™t make it any easier to live in it. Sam, a college-bound teenager, is camping with her dad and her dadโ€™s friend. In a creepy moment of late-night forced intimacy, her dadโ€™s friend makes a highly suggestive remark to her, then walks it back. No harm, no foul, right? By the end of the film, Sam has decided for herself just what that moment meant. A parable, you might even say, for the minefield young women will have to cross in the next four years. –JB

Image: Universal Pictures

5) Wicked โ€“ Hitting the high notes

Jon M. Chuโ€™s adaptation from the stage to the screen will make you believe everyone deserves the chance to fly! There is no denying that Cynthia Erivo and Ariana Grande had fun playing their roles. It is in every move they make. Ariana Grandeโ€™s micro facial expressions during โ€œNo One Mourns the Wickedโ€ had my eyes glued to her! โ€œPopularโ€ had my husbandโ€™s full attention. This movie is worth all the hype. –CD

4) Nickel Boys โ€“ The shed

It was another banner year for horror films at the theaters. The indies led by a prosthetic-laden Nick Cage brought huge returns on modest budgets, a number of modern and classic franchises got new entries, and Sydney Sweeney even fought some evil nuns. Why bring these up here? Nickel Boys isnโ€™t a horror film, even if weโ€™re getting really abstract about the horrors of institutional racism in the 1960s southern United States. Itโ€™s the yearโ€™s best film, where director RaMell Ross uses a unique conceit โ€“ almost the entire film takes place within point of view shots from the perspective of one of its two main characters โ€“ and crafts a drama with an engaging story that gives equal energy to thoughts on perspective, identity, memory. All those things equally art-minded movies struggle to grasp and that Ross examines with his camera, easy as holding an orange against the clear blue sky.

It also contains the most terrifying sequence in movies this year, Longlegs be further damned. The reform school where our two heroes survive day to day has a structure built specifically for corporal punishment. When Elwood (Ethan Herisse) gets sent there, the camera and soundtrack (this is the kind of movie that should get sound award nominations) put us in the waiting room. Not a lick of violence is shown on camera, but lingering effects of violence โ€“ physical, mental, institutional – leap from the screen.

Image: MUBI

3) The Substance – Thus Spoke Zarathustra

For a film that throws bombs gleefully at Hollywood, Coralie Fargeat’s The Substance is packed to the gills (and other body parts) with references to other classic films. The peak is the film’s use of โ€œThus Spoke Zarathustra,โ€ made famous by 2001: A Space Odyssey. The Substance‘s use of the song accompanies the reveal of the next evolution of Sue, which may be the most appropriate use of the song I’ve seen in decades. And the moment is delightfully unhinged, an evolution of the film into a body horror farce that had me calling in the theater. If you’ve seen it, you won’t forget it soon, and if you haven’t, you owe it to yourself to bear witness. โ€“NDL

Image: A24

2) I Saw the TV Glow โ€“ Apologies about nothing to no one

Funny without explicitly cracking a joke and scary without jumping at the camera, Glow is a purposeful guide to the uncanny territories of nostalgia and loneliness, an instant cult classic that evokes a more daring age of indies. Explicitly queer in its conception and allegory, perhaps writer/director Jane Shoenbrunโ€™s most memorable decision is to end the film as a terrifying cautionary tale. Will the entertainment you consume be the conduit to your better self, or a distraction that keeps you from seeking it? Justice Smithโ€™s final portrayal of a life lost even while itโ€™s lived sharpens the movieโ€™s ultimately hopeful message: THERE IS STILL TIME.

1) Anora โ€“ Vegas wedding

Anora winning Best Picture at the Oscars is a โ€œIโ€™ll believe it when I see itโ€ proposition. But much like a recently-wed Ani, thereโ€™s no reason we shouldnโ€™t celebrate the moment while true indie auteur Sean Baker and his lead Mikey Madison get to bask in accolades and adoration. And with good reason โ€“ Anora is both a summary of Bakerโ€™s career to date and the filmmaker finding a new gear. The film balances romance, suspense, humor and even some Coen Brother-esque farce with an infectious energy that makes it free-wheeling even as itโ€™s thoughtful about the problems about to burst through the surface. No wonder the ubiquity of the image of the happily-married-for-now couple under the glaring Las Vegas lights that suggest you can stave off the dark night forever. There may be disaster ahead, but for one moment we can believe it will never come.

Nickel Boys was a venture with major studio money. I Saw the TV Glow showed A24 still rewards new vision. The Substance and Anora made the leap from Cannes to multiplexes. Miracles still happen, at least at the movies.

Image: A24